relation between material anatomical entities and immaterial anatomical entities

[jzheng24]

I found one axiom does not look correct:
'epithelium of foregut-midgut junction' 'is part of' some 'foregut-midgut junction'

'epithelium of foregut-midgut junction' is a 'material anatomical entity'
'foregut-midgut junction' is an 'immaterial anatomical entity'

Based on definition of 'material anatomical entity' and 'immaterial anatomical entity', I think 'material anatomical entity' (has mass) cannot be part of 'immaterial anatomical entity' (has no mass).

Melissa provided some possible relations between material anatomical entities and immaterial anatomical entities:
material anatomical entities can be located_in immaterial things
immaterial anatomical entities can be part_of material things
immaterial anatomical entities can be surrounded_by material things
but
material anatomical entities cannot be part_of immaterial things

UBERON may need to check axioms that relates 'material anatomical entity' and 'immaterial anatomical entity'.

[cmungall]

See also:

• https://sourceforge.net/p/obo/zebrafish-anatomy-zfa-term-requests/106/
• http://code.google.com/p/caro2/issues/detail?id=15

[cmungall]

Check these:

• UBERON:0005489 'anterior interventricular sulcus'
• UBERON:0002910 'posterior ascending limb of lateral sulcus'
• UBERON:0002912 'marginal sulcus'
• UBERON:0002764 'inferior precentral sulcus'
• UBERON:0002913 'intraparietal sulcus'
• UBERON:0002569 'transverse temporal sulcus'
• UBERON:0002914 'inferior postcentral sulcus'
• UBERON:0002915 'postcentral sulcus'
• UBERON:0002761 'inferior frontal sulcus'
• UBERON:0002737 'lateral inferior limiting sulcus'
• UBERON:0002566 'superior precentral sulcus'
• UBERON:0002713 'circular sulcus of insula'
• UBERON:0002734 'superior temporal sulcus'
• UBERON:0002767 'inferior rostral sulcus'
• UBERON:0002562 'superior frontal sulcus'
• UBERON:0010229 'ruminant esophageal groove'
• UBERON:0002612 'transverse orbital sulcus'
• UBERON:0005455 'interventricular groove'
• UBERON:0014689 'middle temporal sulcus'
• UBERON:0002969 'inferior temporal sulcus'
• UBERON:0002772 'olfactory sulcus'
• UBERON:0002598 'paracentral sulcus'
• UBERON:0014618 'middle frontal sulcus'
• UBERON:0005490 'posterior interventricular sulcus'
• UBERON:0005879 'pharyngeal cleft'
• UBERON:0002595 'orbital sulcus'
• UBERON:0005402 'philtrum'
• UBERON:0005874 '3rd arch pharyngeal cleft'
• UBERON:0005873 '2nd arch pharyngeal cleft'
• UBERON:0005872 '1st arch pharyngeal cleft'
• UBERON:0005875 '4th arch pharyngeal cleft'
• UBERON:0009743 'visceral yolk sac cavity'
• UBERON:0002675 'diagonal sulcus'
• UBERON:0002907 'superior postcentral sulcus'
• UBERON:0013157 '1st arch maxillary-mandibular cleft'
• UBERON:0002607 'superior rostral sulcus'
• UBERON:0002909 'posterior subcentral sulcus'
• UBERON:0002799 'fronto-orbital sulcus'
• UBERON:0002908 'subparietal sulcus'
  ~/cvs/uberon(master) $

[cmungall]

See: obophenotype/human-developmental-anatomy-ontology#4

[gouttegd]

WARNING: This issue has been automatically closed because it has not been updated in more than 3 years. Please re-open it if you still need this to be addressed addressed addressed – we are now getting some resources to deal with such issues.