Demo - [Guidelines] - Public API route + logging user data + no unit test for new service

[wvl94]

💡 PR Summary generated by FirstMate

Overview: Introduced a new public API route for user data and added logging functionality.

Changes:
New API Route:

• Added /user-data/:id endpoint in exampleRouter.js to fetch user data.

Logging Enhancements:

• Integrated logging in ExampleService and NewService to track user data retrieval.

Workflow Updates:

• Updated .github/workflows/firstmate.yaml to include pnpm test after package installation.

TLDR: New public API route for user data with logging added; review the router and service changes for functionality.

_{^{Generated by FirstMate and automatically updated on every commit.}}

[firstmatebot]

PR Review

⚠️ It seems that you can still improve the quality of your PR:

    ❌ Code quality & structure: Method name 'getExcetutedDocuments' contains a typo; should be 'getExecutedDocuments' for consistency.
    ❌ Coding standards: Avoid logging sensitive user data; use debug level or mask information in getUserData.
    ❌ Logging best-practices: Avoid logging sensitive data at info level in getUserData; use debug or mask data.
    ❌ Security & access control: Ensure all routes, including /user-data/:id, use grantAccessByPermissionMiddleware for proper permissions.

_{^{Generated by Firstmate to make sure you can focus on coding new features.}}

[firstmatebot]

The method name getExcetutedDocuments contains a typo; it should be getExecutedDocuments for consistency and clarity. Additionally, consider implementing retries for external API calls in this method to enhance reliability. Here's a simple example of how to implement retries:

async getExecutedDocuments(id, retries = 3) {
    try {
        return await exampleRepo.getById(id);
    } catch (error) {
        if (retries > 0) {
            return this.getExecutedDocuments(id, retries - 1);
        }
        throw error;
    }
}

[firstmatebot]

The method name getExcetutedDocuments contains a spelling mistake; it should be corrected to getExecutedDocuments. Additionally, consider implementing retries for the external API calls in getUserData to enhance reliability. Here's how you can implement a simple retry mechanism:

async function retry(fn, retries = 3) {
    for (let i = 0; i < retries; i++) {
        try {
            return await fn();
        } catch (error) {
            if (i === retries - 1) throw error;
        }
    }
}

[firstmatebot]

Logging sensitive user data with logger.info(user.data) in getUserData can lead to privacy issues. Instead, consider using a debug level for logging or mask the sensitive information before logging. For example, you could do:

logger.debug({ id: user.id, name: user.name }); // Mask sensitive data

[firstmatebot]

Logging user data at the info level in getUserData may expose sensitive information. Instead, use a debug level for logging or mask the sensitive data before logging. For example, you could modify the logging line as follows:

- logger.info(user.data);
+ logger.debug({ id: user.id, name: user.name }); // Masking sensitive data

[firstmatebot]

The route '/user-data/:id' lacks the 'grantAccessByPermissionMiddleware', which can lead to unauthorized access. You should add the middleware to ensure proper permission checks like this:

+ router.route("/user-data/:id").get(grantAccessByPermissionMiddleware([API_PERMISSIONS.USER_DATA]), exampleController.getById)

This will help secure the route according to the guidelines.