ISOM 2017-2 #1363
ISOM 2017-2 #1363
Conversation
dg0yt
force-pushed
the
isom_2017-2
branch
2 times, most recently
from
923cbf7 to
bdbfcb3
Compare
We need to retain the original version for now in order to retain the translations which are bound to the 'ISOM2017' context.
"If yellow coloured areas become dominant, a screen (75% instead of full yellow) may be used." (IOF: ISOM 2017-2). For letting symbol set users easily switch between both options, it is neccessary to create a single explicit map color for use with the affected area features. Users now just need to adjust the percentage of yellow in a single place: this map color. All affected symbols will be updated immediately. The original full tone (spot color) "Yellow" must remains unchanged, as base for derived map colors (such as the background for "Narrow ride", or "Yellow 100%/Green 50%" for "Area that shall not be entered"). This implemenation intentionally deviates from IOF Map Commission's "Colours ISOM 2017-2.pdf" which lists separate map colors "Yellow 100% - Area Feature" and "Yellow 75% - Area Feature". That approach would require touching each affected symbol individually.
This color is just above yellow, for implementing black dots for "Cultivated Land" and "Sandy ground". This implementation is based on, but intentionally deviates at least from the naming of, "Black for Cultivated Land" in IOF Map Commission's "Colours ISOM 2017-2.pdf". This implementation is chosen to allow green patches and similar on top of the named symbols.
Increase 20% -> 30%, 50% -> 60%. Do not append "- Area Feature": We will use "Green 60%" also for "[Rough] Open land with scattered trees".
For "[Rough] Open land with scattered trees", now replaced with regular "Green 60%".
Formerly known as "Green 50%/Yellow".
This includes two area symbols and the "Green, Black 50%" color. The line symbol uses regular opaque green for the moment.
Increase Green 20% -> 30%, 50% -> 60%. Change order to match "Colours ISOM 2017-2.pdf".
Create a lower "Brown 50% - Area Feature" in addition to what becomes "Brown 50% - Street Infill" now. Preliminary adjustment of road symbols.
Move existing colors down, and adjust name.
To be used for a dedicated symbol for dominant areas of "Uncrossable body of water".
Intentionally not used for our "Building, minimum size" symbol.
Formerly known as "Opaque White below Black".
Current not used by a symbol.
Older version used to create and save empty start/middle/end/dash point symbols for each line symbol. This is no longer the case. But normally, they are dropped only when editing symbols.
Keep the two variants of Brown 50% close together, above the shades of Blue for area features. Have a Black below each Brown 50%. Update the symbols which need Brown 50% so that they play together well. (Note that the explicit "Paved area, bounding line" symbol now uses "Black below Purple for Track symbols".) For consistent behaviour within our symbol set, and as already implemented in our ISOM2017 symbol set, place the Browns and Blacks above the shades of Blue for area symbols, but below the shades of Black for buildings. This intentionally deviates from IOF Map Commission's color level proposals which seem to be hard to use in practice.
Place it under Blue for area features. This is roughly where it used to be in our ISOM2017 symbol set, properly below Purple for Track Symbols.
...to use "Purple for Track Symbols".
Color overview
|
Partly based on contributions by: Eugeniy Fedirets Yevhen Mazur
Different levels of pure cyan are hard to distinguish on screen. The 22 px custom symbols were created with 5% magenta for Blue 100%, and with halftones reduced (70% -> 50%, 50% -> 25%).
Intentionally using Green+Purple instead of the original Green+Black.
|
Symbol set finished. Direct download for review: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/OpenOrienteering/mapper/84afdd69ad8933133a345698cf29cb4c6b145944/symbol%20sets/src/ISOM%202017-2_15000.xmap |
|
Note: For simplicity, I ignored the traditional, now-deprecated order of spot colors. I assume it will no longer have any use. |
|
Stairways white doesn't cut the blue colors. Intentionally? (Railway-whit cut them) When cheating with too short impassable fence or linear, it might appear two dots/tags and a short line. Wouldnt it be better the other way: the symbols appear first when line is longer then the distance between the "double symbols"? (Same with those symmbols but no "doubes, ordinary fence for example, but the problem is less. |
I wonder if there should be white at all. The ISOM only mentions black.
The question is if "cheating" should be impossible, hard, or convenient. Without the "decorations", the symbol is incomplete and can be misunderstood. |
Required for dashed variant of Distinct vegetation boundary (416), cf. GH-1184.
Use combined symbol based on Open land (401) and the black pattern variant of Cultivated land (412.1).
Attempt to eventually merge the work of @Symbian9 and @yevhenmazur, but documenting major changes and decisions.
Task: GH-1184