CONTRIBUTING.md

Table of Contents

• Contributing to PyTorch
• Developing PyTorch
  • Tips and Debugging
• Nightly Checkout & Pull
• Codebase structure
• Unit testing
  • Python Unit Testing
  • Better local unit tests with pytest
  • Local linting
  • Running mypy
  • C++ Unit Testing
• Writing documentation
  • Building documentation
    • Tips
    • Building C++ Documentation
  • Previewing changes
    • Submitting changes for review
  • Adding documentation tests
• Profiling with py-spy
• Managing multiple build trees
• C++ development tips
  • Build only what you need
  • Code completion and IDE support
  • Make no-op build fast
    • Use Ninja
    • Use CCache
    • Use a faster linker
  • C++ frontend development tips
  • GDB integration
• CUDA development tips
• Windows development tips
  • Known MSVC (and MSVC with NVCC) bugs
• Running clang-tidy
• Pre-commit tidy/linting hook
• Building PyTorch with ASAN
  • Getting ccache to work
  • Why this stuff with LD_PRELOAD and LIBASAN_RT?
  • Why LD_PRELOAD in the build function?
  • Why no leak detection?
• Caffe2 notes
• CI failure tips
  • Which commit is used in CI?

Contributing to PyTorch

Thank you for your interest in contributing to PyTorch! Before you begin writing code, it is important that you share your intention to contribute with the team, based on the type of contribution:

1. You want to propose a new feature and implement it.
   • Post about your intended feature in an issue, and we shall discuss the design and implementation. Once we agree that the plan looks good, go ahead and implement it.
2. You want to implement a feature or bug-fix for an outstanding issue.
   • Search for your issue in the PyTorch issue list.
   • Pick an issue and comment that you'd like to work on the feature or bug-fix.
   • If you need more context on a particular issue, please ask and we shall provide.

Once you implement and test your feature or bug-fix, please submit a Pull Request to https://github.com/pytorch/pytorch.

This document covers some of the more technical aspects of contributing to PyTorch. For more non-technical guidance about how to contribute to PyTorch, see the Contributing Guide.

Developing PyTorch

A full set of instructions on installing PyTorch from source is here: https://github.com/pytorch/pytorch#from-source

To develop PyTorch on your machine, here are some tips:

1. Uninstall all existing PyTorch installs:

conda uninstall pytorch
pip uninstall torch
pip uninstall torch # run this command twice

2. Clone a copy of PyTorch from source:

git clone https://github.com/pytorch/pytorch
cd pytorch

2.1. If you already have PyTorch from source, update it:

git pull --rebase
git submodule sync --recursive
git submodule update --init --recursive

If you want to have no-op incremental rebuilds (which are fast), see the section below titled "Make no-op build fast."

3. Install PyTorch in develop mode:

The change you have to make is to replace

python setup.py install

with

python setup.py develop

This mode will symlink the Python files from the current local source tree into the Python install. Hence, if you modify a Python file, you do not need to reinstall PyTorch again and again. This is especially useful if you are only changing Python files.

For example:

• Install local PyTorch in develop mode
• modify your Python file torch/__init__.py (for example)
• test functionality
• modify your Python file torch/__init__.py
• test functionality
• modify your Python file torch/__init__.py
• test functionality

You do not need to repeatedly install after modifying Python files (.py). However, you would need to reinstall if you modify Python interface (.pyi, .pyi.in) or non-Python files (.cpp, .cc, .cu, .h, ...).

In case you want to reinstall, make sure that you uninstall PyTorch first by running pip uninstall torch and python setup.py clean. Then you can install in develop mode again.

Tips and Debugging

• A prerequisite to installing PyTorch is CMake. We recommend installing it with Homebrew with brew install cmake if you are developing on MacOS or Linux system.
• Our setup.py requires Python >= 3.6
• If a commit is simple and doesn't affect any code (keep in mind that some docstrings contain code that is used in tests), you can add [skip ci] (case sensitive) somewhere in your commit message to skip all build / test steps. Note that changing the pull request body or title on GitHub itself has no effect.
• If you run into errors when running python setup.py develop, here are some debugging steps:
  1. Run printf '#include <stdio.h>\nint main() { printf("Hello World");}'|clang -x c -; ./a.out to make sure your CMake works and can compile this simple Hello World program without errors.
  2. Nuke your build directory. The setup.py script compiles binaries into the build folder and caches many details along the way, which saves time the next time you build. If you're running into issues, you can always rm -rf build from the toplevel pytorch directory and start over.
  3. If you have made edits to the PyTorch repo, commit any change you'd like to keep and clean the repo with the following commands (note that clean really removes all untracked files and changes.):

  git submodule deinit -f .
  git clean -xdf
  python setup.py clean
  git submodule update --init --recursive # very important to sync the submodules
  python setup.py develop                 # then try running the command again

  4. The main step within python setup.py develop is running make from the build directory. If you want to experiment with some environment variables, you can pass them into the command:

  ENV_KEY1=ENV_VAL1[, ENV_KEY2=ENV_VAL2]* python setup.py develop

• If you run into issue running git submodule update --init --recursive. Please try the following:

  • If you encountered error such as

    error: Submodule 'third_party/pybind11' could not be updated
    

    check whether your Git local or global config file contains any submodule.* settings. If yes, remove them and try again. (please reference this doc for more info).

  • If you encountered error such as

    fatal: unable to access 'https://github.com/pybind11/pybind11.git': could not load PEM client certificate ...
    

    this is likely that you are using HTTP proxying and the certificate expired. To check if the certificate is valid, run git config --global --list and search for config like http.proxysslcert=<cert_file>. Then check certificate valid date by running

    openssl x509 -noout -in <cert_file> -dates
    

  • If you encountered error that some third_party modules are not checkout correctly, such as

    Could not find .../pytorch/third_party/pybind11/CMakeLists.txt
    

    remove any submodule.* settings in your local git config (.git/config of your pytorch repo) and try again.

Nightly Checkout & Pull

The tools/nightly.py script is provided to ease pure Python development of PyTorch. This uses conda and git to check out the nightly development version of PyTorch and installs pre-built binaries into the current repository. This is like a development or editable install, but without needing the ability to compile any C++ code.

You can use this script to check out a new nightly branch with the following:

./tools/nightly.py checkout -b my-nightly-branch
conda activate pytorch-deps

Or if you would like to re-use an existing conda environment, you can pass in the regular environment parameters (--name or --prefix):

./tools/nightly.py checkout -b my-nightly-branch -n my-env
conda activate my-env

You can also use this tool to pull the nightly commits into the current branch:

./tools/nightly.py pull -n my-env
conda activate my-env

Pulling will reinstall the PyTorch dependencies as well as the nightly binaries into the repo directory.

Codebase structure

• c10 - Core library files that work everywhere, both server and mobile. We are slowly moving pieces from ATen/core here. This library is intended only to contain essential functionality, and appropriate to use in settings where binary size matters. (But you'll have a lot of missing functionality if you try to use it directly.)
• aten - C++ tensor library for PyTorch (no autograd support)
  • src - README
    • TH THC THCUNN - Legacy library code from the original Torch. Try not to add things here; we're slowly porting these to native.
      • generic - Contains actual implementations of operators, parametrized over scalar_t. Files here get compiled N times per supported scalar type in PyTorch.
    • ATen
      • core - Core functionality of ATen. This is migrating to top-level c10 folder.
      • native - Modern implementations of operators. If you want to write a new operator, here is where it should go. Most CPU operators go in the top level directory, except for operators which need to be compiled specially; see cpu below.
        • cpu - Not actually CPU implementations of operators, but specifically implementations which are compiled with processor-specific instructions, like AVX. See the README for more details.
        • cuda - CUDA implementations of operators.
        • sparse - CPU and CUDA implementations of COO sparse tensor operations
        • mkl mkldnn miopen cudnn
          • implementations of operators which simply bind to some backend library.
        • quantized - Quantized tensor (i.e. QTensor) operation implementations. README contains details including how to implement native quantized operations.
• torch - The actual PyTorch library. Everything that is not in csrc is a Python module, following the PyTorch Python frontend module structure.
  • csrc - C++ files composing the PyTorch library. Files in this directory tree are a mix of Python binding code, and C++ heavy lifting. Consult setup.py for the canonical list of Python binding files; conventionally, they are often prefixed with python_. README
    • jit - Compiler and frontend for TorchScript JIT frontend. README
    • autograd - Implementation of reverse-mode automatic differentiation. README
    • api - The PyTorch C++ frontend.
    • distributed - Distributed training support for PyTorch.
• tools - Code generation scripts for the PyTorch library. See README of this directory for more details.
• test - Python unit tests for PyTorch Python frontend.
  • test_torch.py - Basic tests for PyTorch functionality.
  • test_autograd.py - Tests for non-NN automatic differentiation support.
  • test_nn.py - Tests for NN operators and their automatic differentiation.
  • test_jit.py - Tests for the JIT compiler and TorchScript.
  • ...
  • cpp - C++ unit tests for PyTorch C++ frontend.
    • api - README
    • jit - README
    • tensorexpr - README
  • expect - Automatically generated "expect" files which are used to compare against expected output.
  • onnx - Tests for ONNX export functionality, using both PyTorch and Caffe2.
• caffe2 - The Caffe2 library.
  • core - Core files of Caffe2, e.g., tensor, workspace, blobs, etc.
  • operators - Operators of Caffe2.
  • python - Python bindings to Caffe2.
  • ...
• .circleci - CircleCI configuration management. README

Unit testing

Python Unit Testing

All PyTorch test suites are located in the test folder and start with test_. Run the entire test suite with

python test/run_test.py

or run individual test suites using the command python test/FILENAME.py, where FILENAME represents the file containing the test suite you wish to run.

For example, to run all the TorchScript JIT tests (located at test/test_jit.py), you would run:

python test/test_jit.py

You can narrow down what you're testing even further by specifying the name of an individual test with TESTCLASSNAME.TESTNAME. Here, TESTNAME is the name of the test you want to run, and TESTCLASSNAME is the name of the class in which it is defined.

Going off the above example, let's say you want to run test_Sequential, which is defined as part of the TestJit class in test/test_jit.py. Your command would be:

python test/test_jit.py TestJit.test_Sequential

The hypothesis library must be installed to run the tests. mypy is an optional dependency, and pytest may help run tests more selectively. All these packages can be installed with conda or pip.

Better local unit tests with pytest

We don't officially support pytest, but it works well with our unittest tests and offers a number of useful features for local developing. Install it via pip install pytest.

If you want to just run tests that contain a specific substring, you can use the -k flag:

pytest test/test_nn.py -k Loss -v

The above is an example of testing a change to all Loss functions: this command runs tests such as TestNN.test_BCELoss and TestNN.test_MSELoss and can be useful to save keystrokes.

Local linting

You can run the same linting steps that are used in CI locally via make:

# Lint all files
make lint -j 6  # run lint (using 6 parallel jobs)

# Lint only the files you have changed
make quicklint -j 6

These jobs may require extra dependencies that aren't dependencies of PyTorch itself, so you can install them via this command, which you should only have to run once:

make setup_lint

To run a specific linting step, use one of these targets or see the Makefile for a complete list of options.

# Check for tabs, trailing newlines, etc.
make quick_checks

make flake8

make mypy

make cmakelint

Running mypy

mypy is an optional static type checker for Python. We have multiple mypy configs for the PyTorch codebase, so you can run them all using this command:

make mypy

See Guide for adding type annotations to PyTorch for more information on how to set up mypy and tackle type annotation tasks.

C++ Unit Testing

PyTorch offers a series of tests located in the test/cpp folder. These tests are written in C++ and use the Google Test testing framework. After compiling PyTorch from source, the test runner binaries will be written to the build/bin folder. The command to run one of these tests is ./build/bin/FILENAME --gtest_filter=TESTSUITE.TESTNAME, where TESTNAME is the name of the test you'd like to run and TESTSUITE is the suite that test is defined in.

For example, if you wanted to run the test MayContainAlias, which is part of the test suite ContainerAliasingTest in the file test/cpp/jit/test_alias_analysis.cpp, the command would be:

./build/bin/test_jit --gtest_filter=ContainerAliasingTest.UnionAliasing

Writing documentation

PyTorch uses Google style for formatting docstrings. Length of line inside docstrings block must be limited to 80 characters to fit into Jupyter documentation popups.

Building documentation

To build the documentation:

1. Build and install PyTorch

2. Install the prerequisites

cd docs
pip install -r requirements.txt
# `katex` must also be available in your PATH.
# You can either install katex globally if you have properly configured npm:
# npm install -g katex
# Or if you prefer an uncontaminated global executable environment or do not want to go through the node configuration:
# npm install katex && export PATH="$PATH:$(pwd)/node_modules/.bin"

Note that if you are a Facebook employee using a devserver, yarn may be more convenient to install katex:

yarn global add katex

3. Generate the documentation HTML files. The generated files will be in docs/build/html.

cd docs
make html

Tips

The .rst source files live in docs/source. Some of the .rst files pull in docstrings from PyTorch Python code (for example, via the autofunction or autoclass directives). To vastly shorten doc build times, it is helpful to remove the files you are not working on, only keeping the base index.rst file and the files you are editing. The Sphinx build will produce missing file warnings but will still complete. For example, to work on jit.rst:

cd docs/source
ls | grep rst | grep -v index | grep -v jit | xargs rm

# Make your changes, build the docs, etc.

# Don't commit the deletions!
git add index.rst jit.rst
...

Building C++ Documentation

For C++ documentation (https://pytorch.org/cppdocs), we use Doxygen and then convert it to Sphinx via Breathe and Exhale. Check the Doxygen reference for more information on the documentation syntax.

We run Doxygen in CI (Travis) to verify that you do not use invalid Doxygen commands. To run this check locally, run ./check-doxygen.sh from inside docs/cpp/source.

To build the documentation, follow the same steps as above, but run them from docs/cpp instead of docs.

Previewing changes

To view HTML files locally, you can open the files in your web browser. For example, navigate to file:///your_pytorch_folder/docs/build/html/index.html in a web browser.

If you are developing on a remote machine, you can set up an SSH tunnel so that you can access the HTTP server on the remote machine from your local machine. To map remote port 8000 to local port 8000, use either of the following commands.

# For SSH
ssh my_machine -L 8000:my_machine:8000

# For Eternal Terminal
et my_machine -t="8000:8000"

Then navigate to localhost:8000 in your web browser.

Tip: You can start a lightweight HTTP server on the remote machine with:

python -m http.server 8000 <path_to_html_output>

Alternatively, you can run rsync on your local machine to copy the files from your remote machine:

mkdir -p build cpp/build
rsync -az me@my_machine:/path/to/pytorch/docs/build/html build
rsync -az me@my_machine:/path/to/pytorch/docs/cpp/build/html cpp/build

Submitting changes for review

It is helpful when submitting a PR that changes the docs to provide a rendered version of the result. If your change is small, you can add a screenshot of the changed docs to your PR.

If your change to the docs is large and affects multiple pages, you can host the docs yourself with the following steps, then add a link to the output in your PR. These instructions use GitHub pages to host the docs you have built. To do so, follow these steps to make a repo to host your changed documentation.

GitHub pages expects to be hosting a Jekyll generated website which does not work well with the static resource paths used in the PyTorch documentation. To get around this, you must add an empty file called .nojekyll to your repo.

cd your_github_pages_repo
touch .nojekyll
git add .
git commit
git push

Then, copy built documentation and push the changes:

cd your_github_pages_repo
cp -r ~/my_pytorch_path/docs/build/html/* .
git add .
git commit
git push

Then you should be able to see the changes at your_github_username.github.com/your_github_pages_repo.

Adding documentation tests

It is easy for code snippets in docstrings and .rst files to get out of date. The docs build includes the Sphinx Doctest Extension, which can run code in documentation as a unit test. To use the extension, use the .. testcode:: directive in your .rst and docstrings.

To manually run these tests, follow steps 1 and 2 above, then run:

cd docs
make doctest

Profiling with py-spy

Evaluating the performance impact of code changes in PyTorch can be complicated, particularly if code changes happen in compiled code. One simple way to profile both Python and C++ code in PyTorch is to use py-spy, a sampling profiler for Python that has the ability to profile native code and Python code in the same session.

py-spy can be installed via pip:

$ pip install py-spy

To use py-spy, first write a Python test script that exercises the functionality you would like to profile. For example, this script profiles torch.add:

import torch

t1 = torch.tensor([[1, 1], [1, 1.]])
t2 = torch.tensor([[0, 0], [0, 0.]])

for _ in range(1000000):
    torch.add(t1, t2)

Since the torch.add operation happens in microseconds, we repeat it a large number of times to get good statistics. The most straightforward way to use py-spy with such a script is to generate a flame graph:

$ py-spy record -o profile.svg --native -- python test_tensor_tensor_add.py

This will output a file named profile.svg containing a flame graph you can view in a web browser or SVG viewer. Individual stack frame entries in the graph can be selected interactively with your mouse to zoom in on a particular part of the program execution timeline. The --native command-line option tells py-spy to record stack frame entries for PyTorch C++ code. To get line numbers for C++ code it may be necessary to compile PyTorch in debug mode by prepending your setup.py develop call to compile PyTorch with DEBUG=1. Depending on your operating system it may also be necessary to run py-spy with root privileges.

py-spy can also work in an htop-like "live profiling" mode and can be tweaked to adjust the stack sampling rate, see the py-spy readme for more details.

Managing multiple build trees

One downside to using python setup.py develop is that your development version of PyTorch will be installed globally on your account (e.g., if you run import torch anywhere else, the development version will be used.

If you want to manage multiple builds of PyTorch, you can make use of conda environments to maintain separate Python package environments, each of which can be tied to a specific build of PyTorch. To set one up:

conda create -n pytorch-myfeature
source activate pytorch-myfeature
# if you run python now, torch will NOT be installed
python setup.py develop

C++ development tips

If you are working on the C++ code, there are a few important things that you will want to keep in mind:

1. How to rebuild only the code you are working on.
2. How to make rebuilds in the absence of changes go faster.

Build only what you need

python setup.py build will build everything by default, but sometimes you are only interested in a specific component.

• Working on a test binary? Run (cd build && ninja bin/test_binary_name) to rebuild only that test binary (without rerunning cmake). (Replace ninja with make if you don't have ninja installed).
• Don't need Caffe2? Pass BUILD_CAFFE2=0 to disable Caffe2 build.

On the initial build, you can also speed things up with the environment variables DEBUG, USE_DISTRIBUTED, USE_MKLDNN, USE_CUDA, BUILD_TEST, USE_FBGEMM, USE_NNPACK and USE_QNNPACK.

• DEBUG=1 will enable debug builds (-g -O0)
• REL_WITH_DEB_INFO=1 will enable debug symbols with optimizations (-g -O3)
• USE_DISTRIBUTED=0 will disable distributed (c10d, gloo, mpi, etc.) build.
• USE_MKLDNN=0 will disable using MKL-DNN.
• USE_CUDA=0 will disable compiling CUDA (in case you are developing on something not CUDA related), to save compile time.
• BUILD_TEST=0 will disable building C++ test binaries.
• USE_FBGEMM=0 will disable using FBGEMM (quantized 8-bit server operators).
• USE_NNPACK=0 will disable compiling with NNPACK.
• USE_QNNPACK=0 will disable QNNPACK build (quantized 8-bit operators).
• USE_XNNPACK=0 will disable compiling with XNNPACK.

For example:

DEBUG=1 USE_DISTRIBUTED=0 USE_MKLDNN=0 USE_CUDA=0 BUILD_TEST=0 USE_FBGEMM=0 USE_NNPACK=0 USE_QNNPACK=0 USE_XNNPACK=0 python setup.py develop

For subsequent builds (i.e., when build/CMakeCache.txt exists), the build options passed for the first time will persist; please run ccmake build/, run cmake-gui build/, or directly edit build/CMakeCache.txt to adapt build options.

Code completion and IDE support

When using python setup.py develop, PyTorch will generate a compile_commands.json file that can be used by many editors to provide command completion and error highlighting for PyTorch's C++ code. You need to pip install ninja to generate accurate information for the code in torch/csrc. More information at:

• https://sarcasm.github.io/notes/dev/compilation-database.html

Make no-op build fast

Use Ninja

By default, cmake will use its Makefile generator to generate your build system. You can get faster builds if you install the ninja build system with pip install ninja. If PyTorch was already built, you will need to run python setup.py clean once after installing ninja for builds to succeed.

Use CCache

Even when dependencies are tracked with file modification, there are many situations where files get rebuilt when a previous compilation was exactly the same.

Using ccache in a situation like this is a real time-saver. The ccache manual describes two ways to use ccache. In the PyTorch project, currently only the latter method of masquerading as the compiler via symlinks works for CUDA compilation.

Here are the instructions for installing ccache from source (tested at commit 3c302a7 of the ccache repo):

#!/bin/bash

if ! ls ~/ccache/bin/ccache
then
    set -ex
    sudo apt-get update
    sudo apt-get install -y cmake
    mkdir -p ~/ccache
    pushd ~/ccache
    rm -rf ccache
    git clone https://github.com/ccache/ccache.git
    mkdir -p ccache/build
    pushd ccache/build
    cmake -DCMAKE_INSTALL_PREFIX=${HOME}/ccache -DENABLE_TESTING=OFF -DZSTD_FROM_INTERNET=ON ..
    make -j$(nproc) install
    popd
    popd

    mkdir -p ~/ccache/lib
    mkdir -p ~/ccache/cuda
    ln -s ~/ccache/bin/ccache ~/ccache/lib/cc
    ln -s ~/ccache/bin/ccache ~/ccache/lib/c++
    ln -s ~/ccache/bin/ccache ~/ccache/lib/gcc
    ln -s ~/ccache/bin/ccache ~/ccache/lib/g++
    ln -s ~/ccache/bin/ccache ~/ccache/cuda/nvcc

    ~/ccache/bin/ccache -M 25Gi
fi

export PATH=~/ccache/lib:$PATH
export CUDA_NVCC_EXECUTABLE=~/ccache/cuda/nvcc

Alternatively, ccache provided by newer Linux distributions (e.g. Debian/sid) also works, but the nvcc symlink to ccache as described above is still required.

Note that the original nvcc binary (typically at /usr/local/cuda/bin) must be on your PATH, otherwise ccache will emit the following error:

ccache: error: Could not find compiler "nvcc" in PATH

For example, here is how to install/configure ccache on Ubuntu:

# install ccache
sudo apt install ccache

# update symlinks and create/re-create nvcc link
sudo /usr/sbin/update-ccache-symlinks
sudo ln -s /usr/bin/ccache /usr/lib/ccache/nvcc

# config: cache dir is ~/.ccache, conf file ~/.ccache/ccache.conf
# max size of cache
ccache -M 25Gi  # -M 0 for unlimited
# unlimited number of files
ccache -F 0

# deploy (and add to ~/.bashrc for later)
export PATH="/usr/lib/ccache:$PATH"

It is also possible to install ccache via conda by installing it from the community-maintained conda-forge channel. Here is how to set up ccache this way:

# install ccache
conda install -c conda-forge ccache

# set up ccache compiler symlinks
mkdir ~/ccache
mkdir ~/ccache/lib
mkdir ~/ccache/cuda
ln -s $CONDA_PREFIX/bin/ccache ~/ccache/lib/cc
ln -s $CONDA_PREFIX/bin/ccache ~/ccache/lib/c++
ln -s $CONDA_PREFIX/bin/ccache ~/ccache/lib/gcc
ln -s $CONDA_PREFIX/bin/ccache ~/ccache/lib/g++
ln -s $CONDA_PREFIX/bin/ccache ~/ccache/cuda/nvcc

# update PATH to reflect symlink locations, consider
# adding this to your .bashrc
export PATH=~/ccache/lib:$PATH
export CUDA_NVCC_EXECUTABLE=~/ccache/cuda/nvcc

# increase ccache cache size to 25 GiB
ccache -M 25Gi

To check this is working, do two clean builds of pytorch in a row. The second build should be substantially and noticeably faster than the first build. If this doesn't seem to be the case, check that each of the symlinks above actually link to your installation of ccache. For example, if you followed the first option and installed ccache from source on a Linux machine, running readlink -e $(which g++) should return ~/ccache/bin/ccache.

Use a faster linker

If you are editing a single file and rebuilding in a tight loop, the time spent linking will dominate. The system linker available in most Linux distributions (GNU ld) is quite slow. Use a faster linker, like lld.

The easiest way to use lld this is download the latest LLVM binaries and run:

ln -s /path/to/downloaded/ld.lld /usr/local/bin/ld

C++ frontend development tips

We have very extensive tests in the test/cpp/api folder. The tests are a great way to see how certain components are intended to be used. When compiling PyTorch from source, the test runner binary will be written to build/bin/test_api. The tests use the GoogleTest framework, which you can read up about to learn how to configure the test runner. When submitting a new feature, we care very much that you write appropriate tests. Please follow the lead of the other tests to see how to write a new test case.

GDB integration

If you are debugging pytorch inside GDB, you might be interested in pytorch-gdb. This script introduces some pytorch-specific commands which you can use from the GDB prompt. In particular, torch-tensor-repr prints a human-readable repr of an at::Tensor object. Example of usage:

$ gdb python
GNU gdb (Ubuntu 9.2-0ubuntu1~20.04) 9.2
[...]
(gdb) # insert a breakpoint when we call .neg()
(gdb) break at::native:neg
No source file named at::native.
Make breakpoint pending on future shared library load? (y or [n]) y
Breakpoint 1 (at::native:neg) pending.

(gdb) run
[...]
>>> import torch
>>> t = torch.tensor([1, 2, 3, 4], dtype=torch.float64)
>>> t
tensor([1., 2., 3., 4.], dtype=torch.float64)
>>> t.neg()

Breakpoint 1, at::native::neg (self=...) at [...]/pytorch/aten/src/ATen/native/UnaryOps.cpp:520
520     Tensor neg(const Tensor& self) { return unary_op_impl(self, at::neg_out); }
(gdb) # the default repr of 'self' is not very useful
(gdb) p self
$1 = (const at::Tensor &) @0x7ffff72ed780: {impl_ = {target_ = 0x5555559df6e0}}
(gdb) torch-tensor-repr self
Python-level repr of self:
tensor([1., 2., 3., 4.], dtype=torch.float64)

GDB tries to automatically load pytorch-gdb thanks to the .gdbinit at the root of the pytorch repo. Howevever, auto-loadings is disabled by default, because of security reasons:

$ gdb
warning: File "/path/to/pytorch/.gdbinit" auto-loading has been declined by your `auto-load safe-path' set to "$debugdir:$datadir/auto-load".
To enable execution of this file add
        add-auto-load-safe-path /path/to/pytorch/.gdbinit
line to your configuration file "/home/YOUR-USERNAME/.gdbinit".
To completely disable this security protection add
        set auto-load safe-path /
line to your configuration file "/home/YOUR-USERNAME/.gdbinit".
For more information about this security protection see the
"Auto-loading safe path" section in the GDB manual.  E.g., run from the shell:
        info "(gdb)Auto-loading safe path"
(gdb)

As gdb itself suggests, the best way to enable auto-loading of pytorch-gdb is to add the following line to your ~/.gdbinit (i.e., the .gdbinit file which is in your home directory, not /path/to/pytorch/.gdbinit):

add-auto-load-safe-path /path/to/pytorch/.gdbinit

CUDA development tips

If you are working on the CUDA code, here are some useful CUDA debugging tips:

1. CUDA_DEVICE_DEBUG=1 will enable CUDA device function debug symbols (-g -G). This will be particularly helpful in debugging device code. However, it will slow down the build process for about 50% (compared to only DEBUG=1), so use wisely.
2. cuda-gdb and cuda-memcheck are your best CUDA debugging friends. Unlikegdb, cuda-gdb can display actual values in a CUDA tensor (rather than all zeros).
3. CUDA supports a lot of C++11/14 features such as, std::numeric_limits, std::nextafter, std::tuple etc. in device code. Many of such features are possible because of the --expt-relaxed-constexpr nvcc flag. There is a known issue that ROCm errors out on device code, which uses such stl functions.
4. A good performance metric for a CUDA kernel is the Effective Memory Bandwidth. It is useful for you to measure this metric whenever you are writing/optimizing a CUDA kernel. Following script shows how we can measure the effective bandwidth of CUDA uniform_ kernel.

   import torch
   import time
   size = 128*512
   nrep = 100
   nbytes_read_write = 4 # this is number of bytes read + written by a kernel. Change this to fit your kernel.
   
   for i in range(10):
       a=torch.empty(size).cuda().uniform_()
       torch.cuda.synchronize()
       start = time.time()
       # dry run to alloc
       out = a.uniform_()
       torch.cuda.synchronize()
       start = time.time()
       for i in range(nrep):
         out = a.uniform_()
       torch.cuda.synchronize()
       end = time.time()
       timec = (end-start)/nrep
       print("uniform, size, elements", size, "forward", timec, "bandwidth (GB/s)", size*(nbytes_read_write)*1e-9/timec)
       size *=2

Windows development tips

For building from source on Windows, consult our documentation on it.

Occasionally, you will write a patch which works on Linux, but fails CI on Windows. There are a few aspects in which MSVC (the Windows compiler toolchain we use) is stricter than Linux, which are worth keeping in mind when fixing these problems.

1. Symbols are NOT exported by default on Windows; instead, you have to explicitly mark a symbol as exported/imported in a header file with __declspec(dllexport) / __declspec(dllimport). We have codified this pattern into a set of macros which follow the convention *_API, e.g., TORCH_API inside Caffe2, Aten and Torch. (Every separate shared library needs a unique macro name, because symbol visibility is on a per shared library basis. See c10/macros/Macros.h for more details.)

   The upshot is if you see an "unresolved external" error in your Windows build, this is probably because you forgot to mark a function with *_API. However, there is one important counterexample to this principle: if you want a templated function to be instantiated at the call site, do NOT mark it with *_API (if you do mark it, you'll have to explicitly instantiate all of the specializations used by the call sites.)

2. If you link against a library, this does not make its dependencies transitively visible. You must explicitly specify a link dependency against every library whose symbols you use. (This is different from Linux where in most environments, transitive dependencies can be used to fulfill unresolved symbols.)

3. If you have a Windows box (we have a few on EC2 which you can request access to) and you want to run the build, the easiest way is to just run .jenkins/pytorch/win-build.sh. If you need to rebuild, run REBUILD=1 .jenkins/pytorch/win-build.sh (this will avoid blowing away your Conda environment.)

Even if you don't know anything about MSVC, you can use cmake to build simple programs on Windows; this can be helpful if you want to learn more about some peculiar linking behavior by reproducing it on a small example. Here's a simple example cmake file that defines two dynamic libraries, one linking with the other:

project(myproject CXX)
set(CMAKE_CXX_STANDARD 14)
add_library(foo SHARED foo.cpp)
add_library(bar SHARED bar.cpp)
# NB: don't forget to __declspec(dllexport) at least one symbol from foo,
# otherwise foo.lib will not be created.
target_link_libraries(bar PUBLIC foo)

You can build it with:

mkdir build
cd build
cmake ..
cmake --build .

Known MSVC (and MSVC with NVCC) bugs

The PyTorch codebase sometimes likes to use exciting C++ features, and these exciting features lead to exciting bugs in Windows compilers. To add insult to injury, the error messages will often not tell you which line of code actually induced the erroring template instantiation.

We've found the most effective way to debug these problems is to carefully read over diffs, keeping in mind known bugs in MSVC/NVCC. Here are a few well known pitfalls and workarounds:

• This is not actually a bug per se, but in general, code generated by MSVC is more sensitive to memory errors; you may have written some code that does a use-after-free or stack overflows; on Linux the code might work, but on Windows your program will crash. ASAN may not catch all of these problems: stay vigilant to the possibility that your crash is due to a real memory problem.

• (NVCC) c10::optional does not work when used from device code. Don't use it from kernels. Upstream issue: akrzemi1/Optional#58 and our local issue #10329.

• constexpr generally works less well on MSVC.

  • The idiom static_assert(f() == f()) to test if f is constexpr does not work; you'll get "error C2131: expression did not evaluate to a constant". Don't use these asserts on Windows. (Example: c10/util/intrusive_ptr.h)

• (NVCC) Code you access inside a static_assert will eagerly be evaluated as if it were device code, and so you might get an error that the code is "not accessible".

class A {
  static A singleton_;
  static constexpr inline A* singleton() {
    return &singleton_;
  }
};
static_assert(std::is_same(A*, decltype(A::singleton()))::value, "hmm");

• The compiler will run out of heap space if you attempt to compile files that are too large. Splitting such files into separate files helps. (Example: THTensorMath, THTensorMoreMath, THTensorEvenMoreMath.)

• MSVC's preprocessor (but not the standard compiler) has a bug where it incorrectly tokenizes raw string literals, ending when it sees a ". This causes preprocessor tokens inside the literal like an#endif to be incorrectly treated as preprocessor directives. See https://godbolt.org/z/eVTIJq as an example.

• Either MSVC or the Windows headers have a PURE macro defined and will replace any occurrences of the PURE token in code with an empty string. This is why we have AliasAnalysisKind::PURE_FUNCTION and not AliasAnalysisKind::PURE. The same is likely true for other identifiers that we just didn't try to use yet.

Running clang-tidy

Clang-Tidy is a C++ linter and static analysis tool based on the clang compiler. We run clang-tidy in our CI to make sure that new C++ code is safe, sane and efficient. See the clang-tidy job in our GitHub Workflow's lint.yml file for the simple commands we use for this.

To run clang-tidy locally, follow these steps:

1. Install clang-tidy. First, check if you already have clang-tidy by simply writing clang-tidy in your terminal. If you don't yet have clang-tidy, you should be able to install it easily with your package manager, e.g. by writing apt-get install clang-tidy on Ubuntu. See https://apt.llvm.org for details on how to install the latest version. Note that newer versions of clang-tidy will have more checks than older versions. In our CI, we run clang-tidy-6.0.

2. Use our driver script to run clang-tidy over any changes relative to some git revision (you may want to replace HEAD~1 with HEAD to pick up uncommitted changes). Changes are picked up based on a git diff with the given revision:

python tools/clang_tidy.py -d build -p torch/csrc --diff 'HEAD~1'

Above, it is assumed you are in the PyTorch root folder. path/to/build should be the path to where you built PyTorch from source, e.g. build in the PyTorch root folder if you used setup.py build. You can use -c <clang-tidy-binary> to change the clang-tidy this script uses. Make sure you have PyYaml installed, which is in PyTorch's requirements.txt.

Pre-commit tidy/linting hook

We use clang-tidy and flake8 (installed with flake8-bugbear, flake8-comprehensions, flake8-pyi, and others) to perform additional formatting and semantic checking of code. We provide a pre-commit git hook for performing these checks, before a commit is created:

ln -s ../../tools/git-pre-commit .git/hooks/pre-commit

You'll need to install an appropriately configured flake8; see Lint as you type for documentation on how to do this.

If you haven't set up the pre-commit hook and have already committed files and CI reports flake8 errors, you can run the check locally in your PR branch with:

flake8 $(git diff --name-only $(git merge-base --fork-point master))

fix the code so that no errors are reported when you re-run the above check again, and then commit the fix.

Building PyTorch with ASAN

ASAN is very useful for debugging memory errors in C++. We run it in CI, but here's how to get the same thing to run on your local machine.

First, install LLVM 8. The easiest way is to get prebuilt binaries and extract them to folder (later called $LLVM_ROOT).

Then set up the appropriate scripts. You can put this in your .bashrc:

LLVM_ROOT=<wherever your llvm install is>
PYTORCH_ROOT=<wherever your pytorch checkout is>

LIBASAN_RT="$LLVM_ROOT/lib/clang/8.0.0/lib/linux/libclang_rt.asan-x86_64.so"
build_with_asan()
{
  LD_PRELOAD=${LIBASAN_RT} \
  CC="$LLVM_ROOT/bin/clang" \
  CXX="$LLVM_ROOT/bin/clang++" \
  LDSHARED="clang --shared" \
  LDFLAGS="-stdlib=libstdc++" \
  CFLAGS="-fsanitize=address -fno-sanitize-recover=all -shared-libasan -pthread" \
  CXX_FLAGS="-pthread" \
  USE_CUDA=0 USE_OPENMP=0 BUILD_CAFFE2_OPS=0 USE_DISTRIBUTED=0 DEBUG=1 \
  python setup.py develop
}

run_with_asan()
{
  LD_PRELOAD=${LIBASAN_RT} $@
}

# you can look at build-asan.sh to find the latest options the CI uses
export ASAN_OPTIONS=detect_leaks=0:symbolize=1:strict_init_order=true
export UBSAN_OPTIONS=print_stacktrace=1:suppressions=$PYTORCH_ROOT/ubsan.supp
export ASAN_SYMBOLIZER_PATH=$LLVM_ROOT/bin/llvm-symbolizer

Then you can use the scripts like:

suo-devfair ~/pytorch ❯ build_with_asan
suo-devfair ~/pytorch ❯ run_with_asan python test/test_jit.py

Getting ccache to work

The scripts above specify the clang and clang++ binaries directly, which bypasses ccache. Here's how to get ccache to work:

1. Make sure the ccache symlinks for clang and clang++ are set up (see CONTRIBUTING.md)
2. Make sure $LLVM_ROOT/bin is available on your $PATH.
3. Change the CC and CXX variables in build_with_asan() to point directly to clang and clang++.

Why this stuff with LD_PRELOAD and LIBASAN_RT?

The “standard” workflow for ASAN assumes you have a standalone binary:

1. Recompile your binary with -fsanitize=address.
2. Run the binary, and ASAN will report whatever errors it find.

Unfortunately, PyTorch is a distributed as a shared library that is loaded by a third-party executable (Python). It’s too much of a hassle to recompile all of Python every time we want to use ASAN. Luckily, the ASAN folks have a workaround for cases like this:

1. Recompile your library with -fsanitize=address -shared-libasan. The extra -shared-libasan tells the compiler to ask for the shared ASAN runtime library.
2. Use LD_PRELOAD to tell the dynamic linker to load the ASAN runtime library before anything else.

More information can be found here.

Why LD_PRELOAD in the build function?

We need LD_PRELOAD because there is a cmake check that ensures that a simple program builds and runs. If we are building with ASAN as a shared library, we need to LD_PRELOAD the runtime library, otherwise there will dynamic linker errors and the check will fail.

We don’t actually need either of these if we fix the cmake checks.

Why no leak detection?

Python leaks a lot of memory. Possibly we could configure a suppression file, but we haven’t gotten around to it.

Caffe2 notes

In 2018, we merged Caffe2 into the PyTorch source repository. While the steady state aspiration is that Caffe2 and PyTorch share code freely, in the meantime there will be some separation.

If you submit a PR to only PyTorch or only Caffe2 code, CI will only run for the project you edited. The logic for this is implemented in .jenkins/pytorch/dirty.sh and .jenkins/caffe2/dirty.sh; you can look at this to see what path prefixes constitute changes. This also means if you ADD a new top-level path, or you start sharing code between projects, you need to modify these files.

There are a few "unusual" directories which, for historical reasons, are Caffe2/PyTorch specific. Here they are:

• CMakeLists.txt, Makefile, binaries, cmake, conda, modules, scripts are Caffe2-specific. Don't put PyTorch code in them without extra coordination.

• mypy*, requirements.txt, setup.py, test, tools are PyTorch-specific. Don't put Caffe2 code in them without extra coordination.

CI failure tips

Once you submit a PR or push a new commit to a branch that is in an active PR, CI jobs will be run automatically. Some of these may fail and you will need to find out why, by looking at the logs.

Fairly often, a CI failure might be unrelated to your changes. In this case, you can usually ignore the failure. See the following subsection for more details.

Some failures might be related to specific hardware or environment configurations. In this case, if the job is run by CircleCI, you can ssh into the job's session to perform manual debugging using the following steps:

1. In the CircleCI page for the failed job, make sure you are logged in and then click the Rerun actions dropdown button on the top right. Click Rerun Job with SSH.

2. When the job reruns, a new step will be added in the STEPS tab labelled Set up SSH. Inside that tab will be an ssh command that you can execute in a shell.

3. Once you are connected through ssh, you may need to enter a docker container. Run docker ps to check if there are any docker containers running. Note that your CI job might be in the process of initiating a docker container, which means it will not show up yet. It is best to wait until the CI job reaches a step where it is building pytorch or running pytorch tests. If the job does have a docker container, run docker exec -it IMAGE_ID /bin/bash to connect to it.

4. Now you can find the pytorch working directory, which could be ~/workspace or ~/project, and run commands locally to debug the failure.

For certain Windows failures, it may be useful to have a full Remote Desktop connection. See detailed instructions here for how to set that up after rerunning the job.

Which commit is used in CI?

For CI run on master, this repository is checked out for a given master commit, and CI is run on that commit (there isn't really any other choice). For PRs, however, it's a bit more complicated. Consider this commit graph, where master is at commit A, and the branch for PR #42 (just a placeholder) is at commit B:

       o---o---B (refs/pull/42/head)
      /         \
     /           C (refs/pull/42/merge)
    /           /
---o---o---o---A (refs/heads/master)

There are two possible choices for which commit to use:

1. Checkout commit B, the head of the PR (manually committed by the PR author).
2. Checkout commit C, the hypothetical result of what would happen if the PR were merged into master (automatically generated by GitHub).

This choice depends on several factors; here is the decision tree as of 2021-03-30:

• For CI jobs on CircleCI:
  • If the name of the job (or one of its ancestors in the workflow DAG) contains "xla" or "gcc5", choice 2 is used. This includes the following jobs:
    • pytorch_linux_xenial_py3_6_gcc5_4_build
      • pytorch_cpp_doc_build
      • pytorch_doc_test
      • pytorch_linux_backward_compatibility_check_test
      • pytorch_linux_xenial_py3_6_gcc5_4_jit_legacy_test
      • pytorch_linux_xenial_py3_6_gcc5_4_test
      • pytorch_python_doc_build
    • pytorch_xla_linux_bionic_py3_6_clang9_build
      • pytorch_xla_linux_bionic_py3_6_clang9_test
  • Otherwise, choice 1 is used.
• For CI jobs on GitHub Actions:
  • If the PR was created using ghstack, choice 1 is used.
  • Otherwise, choice 2 is used.

This is important to be aware of, because if you see a CI failure on your PR and choice 2 is being used for that CI job, it is possible that the failure is nondeterministically caused by a commit that does not exist in the ancestry of your PR branch. If you happen to have write access to this repo, you can choose to use ghstack to eliminate this nondeterminism for GitHub Actions jobs on your PRs, but it will still be present for the select CircleCI jobs listed above.