| title | description | published | date | tags | editor | dateCreated |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Block Criteria for a WG in Internal Review |
true |
2022-09-07 14:19:52 UTC |
iesg |
markdown |
2022-09-07 14:19:49 UTC |
- Significant technical concern with the viability of the work
- Significant procedural concern with the ability to complete the work effectively due to low energy levels, contentiousness, overly large scope of the work, etc.
- Lack of technical clarity on what the work and deliverables will actually consist of
- Lack of scope for what is clearly in-bounds versus things that should be explicitly forbidden
- Overlap or interference with other work inside or outside the IETF, which would lead to clear harm or significant operational issues
- Quality of writing and editing poor enough to prevent effective external review of the proposed work
- It's a really really bad idea (e.g. key escrow)
- Inappropriate phasing of the work that may lead to inadequate focus or end-runs of consensus process.
- Out of scope for the IETF.