You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
S3 Compatible Object Storage as Primary Storage Location does not provide instructions how to comply with its "before the first login of any user – including the admin user" bootstrap constraint
#347
Open
posita opened this issue
May 15, 2022
· 0 comments
Read the following implications carefully BEFORE you start using files_primary_s3:
Apply this configuration before the first login of any user – including the admin user; otherwise, ownCloud can no longer find the user’s files.
It provides zero instructions how to do this. The Amazon S3 docs that appear in the same section show only how to use the admin interface (presumably after the admin logs in) to configure anything. Further, there are no instructions how to install the app in the first place, and the likely path of discovery of the app in the first place is after the admin logs in.
It's likely technically possible to comply with this requirement, but it's onerous. The reader is left to guess at how they might accomplish it, and probably only after they've violated the constraint. It would be best to provide an approach that allowed the admin user to log in long enough to install and configure the app and then migrate after the fact. An alternative would be to either link to or more explicitly describe how to meet this requirement directly, but the requirement isn't likely reasonable in the first place. It means that admins can't ever add S3 storage as primary unless it is contemplated from the very beginning of an installation, which is likely very rare.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
posita
changed the title
S3 Compatible Object Storage as Primary Storage Location does not provide instructions how to comply with its "before the first login of any user" constraint.S3 Compatible Object Storage as Primary Storage Location does not provide instructions how to comply with its "before the first login of any user – including the admin user" bootstrap constraint
May 15, 2022
S3 Compatible Object Storage as Primary Storage Location reads, in pertinent part:
It provides zero instructions how to do this. The Amazon S3 docs that appear in the same section show only how to use the admin interface (presumably after the admin logs in) to configure anything. Further, there are no instructions how to install the app in the first place, and the likely path of discovery of the app in the first place is after the admin logs in.
It's likely technically possible to comply with this requirement, but it's onerous. The reader is left to guess at how they might accomplish it, and probably only after they've violated the constraint. It would be best to provide an approach that allowed the admin user to log in long enough to install and configure the app and then migrate after the fact. An alternative would be to either link to or more explicitly describe how to meet this requirement directly, but the requirement isn't likely reasonable in the first place. It means that admins can't ever add S3 storage as primary unless it is contemplated from the very beginning of an installation, which is likely very rare.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: