Did mobile version support memo?

[katopz]

Refer to https://github.com/solana-labs/solana-pay/blob/master/SPEC.md#memo
But after I try it seem like memo is not support and there's no information about this on docs.

It would be nice if we support memo so we can know what this tx is reference to.

IMHO: This is another show stopper for simple integration use case (just pay without sign-in) because redirect also not support

which mean the only way to do this is include plenty of lib for build the tx and force user to connect wallet and pay (2 steps) or use in-app webview (still needed to sign-in implementation) while we can use reference_id or redirect_url callback for payment (1 step).

Thanks

[adamdelphantom]

Hey @katopz,

I understand this is not included in the docs. Have you attempted passing a transaction with memo field and seeing if it is accessible? I don't have a way to readily test right now but I believe we may already support the memo field.

[katopz]

Oh it's not transaction case, I tend to use just 1 line deeplink so no setup or web3.js needed here.

refer to solana example

solana:mvines9iiHiQTysrwkJjGf2gb9Ex9jXJX8ns3qwf2kN?amount=1&label=Michael&message=Thanks%20for%20all%20the%20fish&memo=OrderId12345

• Yes, I attempt to pass the memo param many times.
• No, I can't make it work.
• No memo on confirmation screen.
• No memo related in final tx.
• The final tx is just transfer both sol and spl.

And that 1 line link is the point.

• Yes, I can build my own tx with memo then ask wallet to signAndSendTransaction which I do that for living via js, Rust, wasm.
• But no, I'm here asking for memo support so I (and other thousand of developer) don't needed to use any web3 library at all.(say mass adoption = easy integration = no node_modules = just 1 line and phantom will take care of it = we love phantom)

I can understand that transfer with memo can be complicate and somehow not wallet side concern.
But to become the wallet that we can 100% love and trust, we should support this simple real world use case so newcomer can just use it with 1 line I think.

And this doable, even has a spec for it so please support it or maybe just say something about it in docs if it's not or plan to.

Thanks for your time.