Type declarations should not inline type definitions

[wertzui]

After upgrading to the latest version, VS code tells me that there is a problem when I pass an Item to triggers.ItemStateChangeTrigger, because Item does not expose "__#5@#getToggleState"(): "PAUSE" | "PLAY" | "OPEN" | "CLOSED" | "ON" | "OFF" which is defined here

openhab-js/types/triggers.d.ts

Line 36 in 7f2b7a4

"__#6@#getToggleState"(): "PAUSE" | "PLAY" | "OPEN" | "CLOSED" | "ON" | "OFF";

and got introduced with 2348409.

Besides this method definition being obviously wrong (It should probably be getToggleState(): "PAUSE" | "PLAY" | "OPEN" | "CLOSED" | "ON" | "OFF"), I think triggers.d.ts should not expose its own Item definition, but rather use the one from items.d.ts.

[florian-h05]

#394 fixes the issue with "__#5@#getToggleState"(): "PAUSE" | "PLAY" | "OPEN" | "CLOSED" | "ON" | "OFF" by not making this method private anymore.

I think triggers.d.ts should not expose its own Item definition, but rather use the one from items.d.ts.

Yes, but our type definitions are emitted by the TypeScript compiler, which currently inlines type definitions.
This is an upstream issue: microsoft/TypeScript#37151

[Dopeyr]

This might be solvable with Typescript 5.5, ref: microsoft/TypeScript#22160

Adding

/**
 * @import { Item } from './items/items'
 */

to triggers.js no longer adds the export of the Item type, so vscode does not suggest Item from triggers.js.

However, the resulting type def in in types/triggers.d.ts is:

/**
 * Creates a trigger that fires upon an Item changing state.
 *
 * @example
 * ItemStateChangeTrigger('my_item'); // changed
 * ItemStateChangeTrigger('my_item', 'OFF', 'ON'); // changed from OFF to ON
 * ItemStateChangeTrigger('my_item', undefined, 'ON'); // changed to ON
 * ItemStateChangeTrigger('my_item', 'OFF', undefined); // changed from OFF
 *
 * @memberof triggers
 * @param {Item|string} itemOrName the {@link Item} or the name of the Item to monitor for change
 * @param {string} [oldState] the previous state of the Item
 * @param {string} [newState] the new state of the Item
 * @param {string} [triggerName] the optional name of the trigger to create
 */
export function ItemStateChangeTrigger(itemOrName: {
    new (rawItem: HostItem): {
        rawItem: HostItem;
        persistence: import("./items/item-persistence");
        semantics: import("./items/item-semantics");
        readonly type: string;
        readonly name: string;
        readonly label: string;
        readonly state: string;
        readonly numericState: number;
        readonly quantityState: import("./quantity").Quantity;
        readonly rawState: HostState;
        readonly members: any[];
        readonly descendents: any[];
        readonly isUninitialized: boolean;
        getMetadata(namespace?: string): {
            namespace: ItemMetadata;
        } | ItemMetadata | null;
        replaceMetadata(namespace: string, value: string, configuration?: object): {
            configuration: any;
            value: string;
        } | null;
        removeMetadata(namespace?: string): ItemMetadata | null;
        sendCommand(value: string | number | JSJoda.ZonedDateTime | Quantity | HostState): void;
        sendCommandIfDifferent(value: string | number | JSJoda.ZonedDateTime | Quantity | HostState): boolean;
        sendIncreaseCommand(value: number | Quantity | HostState): boolean;
        sendDecreaseCommand(value: number | Quantity | HostState): boolean;
        getToggleState(): "PAUSE" | "PLAY" | "OPEN" | "CLOSED" | "ON" | "OFF";
        sendToggleCommand(): void;
        postToggleUpdate(): void;
        postUpdate(value: string | number | JSJoda.ZonedDateTime | Quantity | HostState): void;
        readonly groupNames: string[];
        addGroups(...groupNamesOrItems: any[]): void;
        removeGroups(...groupNamesOrItems: any[]): void;
        readonly tags: string[];
        addTags(...tagNames: string[]): void;
        removeTags(...tagNames: string[]): void;
        toString(): any;
    };
} | string, oldState?: string, newState?: string, triggerName?: string): HostTrigger;

Which looks a bit odd...

[florian-h05]

I played around with TS 5.5 and was not able to solve the issue by using @import ...

[Dopeyr]

I think it solves one issue with the autosuggest, and introduces another.

Currently Item is suggested from multiple files (note it includes triggers as it's exported there)

After TS 5.5 and adding @import to triggers.js, it no longer suggests Item from triggers

But when autosuggesting the parameters for ItemStateChangeTrigger (for example) the auto complete is horrible

[florian-h05]

Ultimately I think we won’t have a solution here as long as microsoft/TypeScript#37151 is open.