Multiplicity of Relationships (Lights and Transponder Beacons) in FC 1.2.0

[kusala9]

There seems to be three mandatory relationships required for LightAllAround according to the latest FC 1.2.0

Mandatory Feature Bindings from the 1.2.0 FC for LightAllAround. this would require one from each group to be associated. They also all have the same asssociation and role, so could all be combined. DCEG doesn't mandate any relationships at all.

Seems to also affect Fog, Sectored and Air Obstruction Lights too.

                  <S100FC:featureBinding roleType="composition">
                        <S100FC:multiplicity>
                              <S100Base:lower>1</S100Base:lower>
                              <S100Base:upper xsi:nil="false" infinite="false">1</S100Base:upper>
                        </S100FC:multiplicity>
                        <S100FC:association ref="StructureEquipment"/>
                        <S100FC:role ref="supportedBy"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="Bridge"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="Building"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="Crane"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="CardinalBeacon"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="CardinalBuoy"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="Conveyor"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="Dolphin"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="EmergencyWreckMarkingBuoy"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="FishingFacility"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="FloatingDock"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="FortifiedStructure"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="Hulk"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="InstallationBuoy"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="IsolatedDangerBeacon"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="IsolatedDangerBuoy"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="Landmark"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="LateralBeacon"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="LateralBuoy"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="LightFloat"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="LightVessel"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="MooringBuoy"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="OffshorePlatform"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="Pile"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="PipelineOverhead"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="Pontoon"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="PylonBridgeSupport"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="SafeWaterBeacon"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="SafeWaterBuoy"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="ShorelineConstruction"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="SiloTank"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="SpanFixed"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="SpanOpening"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="SpecialPurposeGeneralBeacon"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="SpecialPurposeGeneralBuoy"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="WindTurbine"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="Wreck"/>
                  </S100FC:featureBinding>
                  <S100FC:featureBinding roleType="composition">
                        <S100FC:multiplicity>
                              <S100Base:lower>1</S100Base:lower>
                              <S100Base:upper xsi:nil="false" infinite="false">1</S100Base:upper>
                        </S100FC:multiplicity>
                        <S100FC:association ref="StructureEquipment"/>
                        <S100FC:role ref="supportedBy"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="LightAllAround"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="LightSectored"/>
                  </S100FC:featureBinding>
 
                  <S100FC:featureBinding roleType="composition">
                        <S100FC:multiplicity>
                              <S100Base:lower>1</S100Base:lower>
                              <S100Base:upper xsi:nil="false" infinite="false">1</S100Base:upper>
                        </S100FC:multiplicity>
                        <S100FC:association ref="StructureEquipment"/>
                        <S100FC:role ref="supportedBy"/>
                        <S100FC:featureType ref="Daymark"/>
                  </S100FC:featureBinding>

[kusala9]

RadarTransponderBeacon has the same affliction - mandatory relationships which aren't in the DCEG.
Daymark has mandatory relationships which aren't in the DCEG. Composition/SupportedBy

[kusala9]

These are all Composition/StructureEquipment and role SupportedBy so they shouldn't be different groups, they should all be a single F->F relationship with the features in a single list. Not sure why they've been split into subgroups. It's not a validation problem but it's inconsistent and it makes automated validation and editing a problem as they have to be joined together first.

[kusala9]

CautionArea. FC 1.2.0 says every CautionArea must have at least one association to an ASL or TSS.

[kusala9]

TrafficSeparationScheme. Seems to have mandatory relationships in 4 associations.

[kusala9]

Fairway.

[kusala9]

FogSignal (I think)

[kusala9]

signalStationWarning and signalStastionTraffic. All seem to be composition relationships set to 1

[kusala9]

RangeSystem
RangeSystem (componentOf) seems to have disappeared (or wasn't in 1.1 anyway).

[kusala9]

I automated the search, eventually. Below is a list of all duplicate relationships (i.e. the same role/association/roletype) and also any mandatory relationships (some I think are ok, e.g. TextPlacement and IslandAggregation). These should all be fixed in the FC prior to 2.0.0 (and, really, in the 1.2.X timeframe as they affect validation of any test data). Quite a few of the mandatories are fixed in the 1.2.X that is in the PC repo. I may fix the grouping issues too, time permitting. If I can find someone I will get the other issues fixed too.

F UpdateInformation: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:UpdatedInformation:identifies [178 features ]
F IslandGroup: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:IslandAggregation:consistsOf [2 features ]
F Building: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F Building: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F Bridge: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F Bridge: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F SpanFixed: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F SpanFixed: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F SpanOpening: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F SpanOpening: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F Conveyor: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F Conveyor: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F PipelineOverhead: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F PipelineOverhead: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F PylonBridgeSupport: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F PylonBridgeSupport: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F PylonBridgeSupport: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F Landmark: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F Landmark: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F Landmark: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F SiloTank: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F WindTurbine: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F WindTurbine: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F FortifiedStructure: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F FortifiedStructure: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F Hulk: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F Pile: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F Pile: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F ShorelineConstruction: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F ShorelineConstruction: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F DistanceMark: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [36 features ]
F DistanceMark: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [1 features ]
F DistanceMark: ERROR - COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy already exists for this feature
F Crane: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F Crane: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F Dolphin: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F Dolphin: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F Bollard: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [8 features ]
F MooringTrot: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:MooringTrotAggregation:consistsOf [4 features ]
F Wreck: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F FishingFacility: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F OffshorePlatform: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F OffshorePlatform: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F OffshorePlatform: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F RangeSystem: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:RangeSystemAggregation:consistsOf [19 features ]
F Fairway: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:FairwayAuxiliary:hasAuxiliary [22 features ]
F FairwaySystem: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf [15 features ]
F FairwaySystem: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf [10 features ]
F FairwaySystem: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf already exists for this feature
F FairwaySystem: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf [10 features ]
F FairwaySystem: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf already exists for this feature
F FairwaySystem: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:FairwayAggregation:consistsOf [1 features ]
F TwoWayRoute: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf [15 features ]
F TwoWayRoute: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf [10 features ]
F TwoWayRoute: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf already exists for this feature
F TwoWayRoute: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf [10 features ]
F TwoWayRoute: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf already exists for this feature
F TwoWayRoute: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:TwoWayRouteAggregation:consistsOf [1 features ]
F DeepWaterRoute: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf [15 features ]
F DeepWaterRoute: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf [10 features ]
F DeepWaterRoute: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf already exists for this feature
F DeepWaterRoute: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:DeepWaterRouteAggregation:consistsOf [2 features ]
F TrafficSeparationScheme: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf [15 features ]
F TrafficSeparationScheme: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf [10 features ]
F TrafficSeparationScheme: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf already exists for this feature
F TrafficSeparationScheme: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf [10 features ]
F TrafficSeparationScheme: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf already exists for this feature
F TrafficSeparationScheme: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:TrafficSeparationSchemeAggregation:consistsOf [14 features ]
F ArchipelagicSeaLane: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf [15 features ]
F ArchipelagicSeaLane: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:ASLAggregation:consistsOf [2 features ]
F CautionArea: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:CautionAreaAssociation:consistsOf [2 features ]
F LightAllAround: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [36 features ]
F LightAllAround: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [2 features ]
F LightAllAround: ERROR - COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy already exists for this feature
F LightAllAround: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [1 features ]
F LightAllAround: ERROR - COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy already exists for this feature
F LightSectored: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [23 features ]
F LightSectored: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [2 features ]
F LightSectored: ERROR - COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy already exists for this feature
F LightSectored: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [1 features ]
F LightSectored: ERROR - COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy already exists for this feature
F LightFogDetector: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [36 features ]
F LightFogDetector: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [2 features ]
F LightFogDetector: ERROR - COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy already exists for this feature
F LightFogDetector: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [1 features ]
F LightFogDetector: ERROR - COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy already exists for this feature
F LightAirObstruction: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [10 features ]
F LightAirObstruction: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [2 features ]
F LightAirObstruction: ERROR - COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy already exists for this feature
F LateralBeacon: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F CardinalBeacon: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F IsolatedDangerBeacon: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F SafeWaterBeacon: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F SpecialPurposeGeneralBeacon: ERROR - ASSOCIATION:StructureEquipment:supports already exists for this feature
F Daymark: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [36 features ]
F Retroreflector: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [36 features ]
F Retroreflector: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [2 features ]
F Retroreflector: ERROR - COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy already exists for this feature
F Retroreflector: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [1 features ]
F Retroreflector: ERROR - COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy already exists for this feature
F RadarReflector: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [2 features ]
F FogSignal: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [36 features ]
F FogSignal: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [2 features ]
F FogSignal: ERROR - COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy already exists for this feature
F FogSignal: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [1 features ]
F FogSignal: ERROR - COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy already exists for this feature
F PhysicalAISAidToNavigation: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [36 features ]
F PhysicalAISAidToNavigation: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [1 features ]
F PhysicalAISAidToNavigation: ERROR - COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy already exists for this feature
F RadarTransponderBeacon: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [36 features ]
F RadarTransponderBeacon: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [2 features ]
F RadarTransponderBeacon: ERROR - COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy already exists for this feature
F RadarTransponderBeacon: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [1 features ]
F RadarTransponderBeacon: ERROR - COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy already exists for this feature
F SignalStationWarning: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [36 features ]
F SignalStationWarning: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [1 features ]
F SignalStationWarning: ERROR - COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy already exists for this feature
F SignalStationTraffic: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [36 features ]
F SignalStationTraffic: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [1 features ]
F SignalStationTraffic: ERROR - COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy already exists for this feature
F TextPlacement: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:TextAssociation:identifies [151 features ]

[TomRichardson6]

KHOA is now preparing an updated FC which will address these changes, Issue to be closed once this version is available.

[kusala9]

Received new version of feature catalogue. There are still some mandatory relationships which aren't in the DCEG and should be removed. These are listed below.

Additionally, the FairwaySystem and TwoWayRoute mandatory associations in the feature catalogue I believe should also be of type "AGGREGATION" and are in the FC as "ASSOCIATION" type which is a mismatch. These are listed below (don't delete these :) :

• F FairwaySystem: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:FairwayAggregation:consistsOf [1 features ]
• F TwoWayRoute: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:TwoWayRouteAggregation:consistsOf [1 features ]

these are still present and, I believe, incorrect with respect of the DCEG.

F UpdateInformation: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:UpdatedInformation:identifies [178 features ]
F IslandGroup: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:IslandAggregation:consistsOf [2 features ]
F DistanceMark: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [37 features ]
F Bollard: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [8 features ]
F MooringTrot: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:MooringTrotAggregation:consistsOf [4 features ]
F RangeSystem: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:RangeSystemAggregation:consistsOf [19 features ]
F FairwaySystem: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf [35 features ]
F TwoWayRoute: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf [35 features ]
F DeepWaterRoute: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf [25 features ]
F DeepWaterRoute: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:DeepWaterRouteAggregation:consistsOf [2 features ]
F ArchipelagicSeaLane: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:AidsToNavigationAssociation:consistsOf [15 features ]
F ArchipelagicSeaLane: WARNING: Mandatory relationship ASSOCIATION:ASLAggregation:consistsOf [2 features ]
F SignalStationWarning: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [37 features ]
F SignalStationTraffic: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:StructureEquipment:supportedBy [37 features ]
F TextPlacement: WARNING: Mandatory relationship COMPOSITION:TextAssociation:identifies [151 features ]

[JeffWootton]

I think this Issue has been overtaken by events (including the creation of the new Issue #140).

Close issue, pending further requirements.