Please remove or clearly mark all resolvers or example DIDs that are using deprecated or invalid structures or are just broken #330
Comments
|
@letmaik Thanks for pointing this out! Since this is a DIF open-source project, anyone can contribute and improve it. Perhaps you would have time to reach out to some of the driver developers and let them know about these issues, and maybe ask them to fix them? |
|
fixed the issue for did:oyd:zQmNauTUUdkpi5TcrTZ2524SKM8dJAzuuw4xfW13iHrtY1W%40did2.data-container.net (expired certificate on https://did2.data-container.net) |
|
@letmaik your posting inspired my to write a machine-readable definition of the W3C DID Core Spec (mainly based on SHACL) and in this way creating a DID Lint service. An early version is available here: https://didlint.ownyourdata.eu/ Iterating with the above validation mechanism over the Test Identifiers from the Uniresolver plugins show actually a quite dire picture: validation results Any feedback on the DID Lint service is much appreciated! |
|
@fabianekc This is awesome, great work! |
|
I agree, this is really nice. We put it on the agenda for the ID WG 2 weeks from now: https://github.com/decentralized-identity/identifiers-discovery/blob/main/agenda.md#meeting---02-january-2023---1400-et |
It confuses the heck out of people and is just not a good look. Nearly all DIDs listed in the examples dropdown of https://dev.uniresolver.io/ return DID documents that are either not following the current spec, using deprecated things, or are broken (no response). I'm assuming this is because some resolvers haven't been updated in a long time, or because the examples are just outdated (for methods that store an actual DID document), or because the DID methods themselves are outdated.
did:ace:0xf81c16a78b257c10fddf87ed4324d433317169a005ddf36a3a1ba937ba9788e3
Contains deprecated
"publicKey".did:ala:quor:redT:3729a1872356dd5c5ac377c85d539fe63cb561d8
Contains deprecated
"publicKey".did:bba:47ef0798566073ea302b8178943aaa83f227614d6f36a4d2bcd92993bbed6044
Contains deprecated
"publicKey".did:bba:t:45e6df15dc0a7d91dcccd24fda3b52c3983a214fb0eed0938321c11ec99403cf
Contains
"publicKeyPem", lacks"controller"within verification method. I found https://w3c-ccg.github.io/ld-cryptosuite-registry/#rsasignature2018 but clearly this is not how it should be done today.did:btcr:x705-jznz-q3nl-srs
Returns nothing. Completely broken?
did:ccp:3CzQLF3qfFVQ1CjGVzVRZaFXrjAd
Uses deprecated
"publicKey".did:cheqd:mainnet:zF7rhDBfUt9d1gJPjx7s1JXfUY7oVWkY
Uses
"Ed25519VerificationKey2020"without including"https://w3id.org/security/suites/ed25519-2020/v1"in"@context".did:com:17rhmdzlv0zjuahw4mvpfhf3u5tuwyjhr4m06dr
Uses uppercase fields, e.g.,
"ID"and"Type".did:dns:danubetech.com
Uses
"Ed25519VerificationKey2020"without including"https://w3id.org/security/suites/ed25519-2020/v1"in"@context".did:dock:5CDsD8HZa6TeSfgmMcxAkbSXYWeob4jFQmtU6sxr4XWTZzUA
Uses deprecated
"publicKey".did:dyne:controller:DwPLgTPBjVwDqoLQV8gbuCiTVEHrHMPmufn8T2DZwjRQ
Wraps the DID document in a
"DID"property.did:elem:ropsten:EiCtwD11AV9e1oISQRHnMJsBC3OBdYDmx8xeKeASrKaw6A
No response, broken?
did:emtrust:0x242a5ac36676462bd58a
Uses deprecated
"publicKey". Also, doesn't actually include a public key, weird.did:ethr:0x03fdd57adec3d438ea237fe46b33ee1e016eda6b585c3e27ea66686c2ea5358479
Uses deprecated
"publicKeyHex".did:everscale:47325e80e3cef5922d3a3583ae5c405ded7bda781cb069f2bc932a6c3d6ec62e
No response, broken?
did:factom:testnet:6aa7d4afe4932885b5b6e93accb5f4f6c14bd1827733e05e3324ae392c0b2764
No response, broken?
did:gatc:2xtSori9UQZdTqzxrkp7zqKM4Kj5B4C7
No response, broken?
did:github:gjgd
No response, broken?
did:hcr:0f674e7e-4b49-4898-85f6-96176c1e30de
No response, broken?
did:icon:01:64aa0a2a479cb47afbf2d18d6f9f216bcdcbecdda27ccba3
Uses deprecated
"publicKey", and"publicKeyBase64"without any reference in"@context".did:io:0x476c81C27036D05cB5ebfe30ae58C23351a61C4A
Uses deprecated
"publicKeyHex".did:ion:EiClkZMDxPKqC9c-umQfTkR8vvZ9JPhl_xLDI9Nfk38w5w
"id"values are not absolute.did:jolo:e76fb4b4900e43891f613066b9afca366c6d22f7d87fc9f78a91515be24dfb21
No response, broken?
did:jwk:eyJraWQiOiJ1cm46aWV0ZjpwYXJhbXM6b2F1dGg6andrLXRodW1icHJpbnQ6c2hhLTI1NjpGZk1iek9qTW1RNGVmVDZrdndUSUpqZWxUcWpsMHhqRUlXUTJxb2JzUk1NIiwia3R5IjoiT0tQIiwiY3J2IjoiRWQyNTUxOSIsImFsZyI6IkVkRFNBIiwieCI6IkFOUmpIX3p4Y0tCeHNqUlBVdHpSYnA3RlNWTEtKWFE5QVBYOU1QMWo3azQifQ
"id"values are not absolute.did:lit:AEZ87t1bi5bRxmVh3ksMUi
No response, broken?
did:meta:0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000005e65
Uses deprecated
"publicKey"and"publicKeyHex".did:moncon:z6MkfrVYbLejh9Hv7Qmx4B2P681wBfPFkcHkbUCkgk1Q8LoA
No response, broken?
did:mydata:z6MkjNiGktLUrNrwMW6obMR85UsjYmLPFmcXc9qaiAGqPaJT
No response, broken?
did:nacl:Md8JiMIwsapml_FtQ2ngnGftNP5UmVCAUuhnLyAsPxI
Uses deprecated
"publicKey", and"publicKeyBase64"without reference in"@context".did:ont:AN5g6gz9EoQ3sCNu7514GEghZurrktCMiH
Uses deprecated
"publicKey"and"publicKeyHex".did:orb:hl:uEiBuxTFn4L_Hn8KsOWo8e9kqWP38MThBaToB_5yV3c5QTg:uoQ-BeEJpcGZzOi8vYmFma3JlaWRveXV5d3B5Zjd5NnA0Zmxiem5pNmh4d2prbGQ2N3ltanlpZnV0dWFwN3RzazUzdHNxank:EiD_igS1OSEftg5BGfisJGOS1rgcx5AkQhX0h1B4dHTUYA
No response, broken?
did:oyd:zQmNauTUUdkpi5TcrTZ2524SKM8dJAzuuw4xfW13iHrtY1W%40did2.data-container.net
No response, broken?
did:schema:public-ipfs:json-schema:Qma2beXKwZeiUXcaRaQKwbBV1TqyiJnsMTYExUTdQue43J
No response, broken?
did:stack:v0:16EMaNw3pkn3v6f2BgnSSs53zAKH4Q8YJg-0
No response, broken?
did:tz:delphinet:tz1WvvbEGpBXGeTVbLiR6DYBe1izmgiYuZbq
No response, broken?
did:unisot:test:n1aAmTXAg4o44Z9k8YCQncEY91r3TV7WU4
Uses deprecated
"publicKey".did:vaa:3wJVWDQWtDFx27FqvSqyo5xsTsxC
Uses deprecated
"publicKey", and"publicKeyPem"without reference in"@context".did:web:did.actor:alice
Uses deprecated
"publicKey".did:web:did.actor:bob
Uses deprecated
"publicKey", has an empty"controller", and"id"is not absolute.did:web:did.actor:carol
Uses deprecated
"publicKey", has an empty"controller", and"id"is not absolute.did:web:did.actor:mike
"id"is not absolute.did:web:identity.foundation
It just has
"id". Technically valid, but... what's the point?did:work:2UUHQCd4psvkPLZGnWY33L
Uses deprecated
"publicKey".The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: