Evaluation

[bensoltoff]

Evaluation of final project by Benjamin Soltoff

Topic	Excellent	Satisfactory	Needs Work
Coding style		x
Coding strategy		x
Presentation: graphs	x
Presentation: tables	x
Achievement, creativity	x
Ease of access	x

Remarks:

• This is a really interesting project and put together in such short time, it still is a clean example of computational analysis
• Nice use of figures and tables to present the results
• Good work in the modeling section finding the comparable set of faculty/OAA that did not sign the letter. I wonder if there's a way to automate collecting the directory or if it can be obtained in bulk. This way you wouldn't have to limit the analysis to the hand coded sample of departments
• Nice use of a data pipeline to run the code. In the future consider if it makes sense to generate the graphs and models in the R Markdown document itself. Then you can include the code in the output. Even if you don't want to directly show the code, you could store it in collapsable chunks like @JordanAMartin did
• Some of the code could be written more efficiently. For instance, why create both tenurestatus and division? You could have stored that in one data frame rather than two.