You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
I've been experimenting with wwaEpv00 and wwaApco and seem to be getting different results depending on whether I use the current WWA NuGet package or source code.
Consider this input for wwaEpv00:
double jd1 = 2456122.0;
double jd2 = -0.374222409930591;
Using the NuGet package, SOFA C code (included in WWA source), liberfa I get these results:
pvh:
[0, 0]: 0.36358010848826561
[0, 1]: -0.87098205453928734
[0, 2]: -0.37758762761290249
[1, 0]: 0.015790881726547225
[1, 1]: 0.0055821572243759544
[1, 2]: 0.0024205553276501913
When I invoke wwaApco using the NuGet package I get these results:
along: -1.2915436465043553
bm1: 0.99999999512048543
bpn: {double[3, 3]}
cphi: 0.75126413350351118
diurab: 0
eb: {double[3]}
eh: {double[3]}
em: 1.0165646807820918
eral: 4.5769545981283493
phi: 0
pmt: 12.530118487590943
refa: 0
refb: 0
sphi: 0.66000166796093673
v: {double[3]}
xpl: 2.0531311761394749E-06
ypl: -4.567827 644945285E-10
If I use the latest version of the source (as well as SOFA C code & liberfa) I get this:
along: -1.2915436465049144 // Last 4 digits different when compared to NuGet package
bm1: 0.99999999512048543
bpn: {double[3, 3]}
cphi: 0.75126413350351118
diurab: 0
eb: {double[3]}
eh: {double[3]}
em: 1.0165646807820918 eral: -1.706230709051797 // Different 4.5769545981283493 compared to -1.706230709051797 phi: 0 // -9.2559631349317831e+61 for SOFA, 2.999580946071453e-67 for liberfa
pmt: 12.530118487590943
refa: 0
refb: 0
sphi: 0.66000166796093673
v: {double[3]}
xpl: 2.0531311761393859E-06 // // Last 4 digits different when compared to NuGet package
ypl: -4.567827 0628706951E-10 // Different after the 6th digit when compared to NuGet package
So wwaApco seems closer to what I expect in the lastest source, but wwaEv00 seems worse.
Not sure if this is expected or if I'm doing something wrong?
Thanks
Greg
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
I've been experimenting with wwaEpv00 and wwaApco and seem to be getting different results depending on whether I use the current WWA NuGet package or source code.
Consider this input for wwaEpv00:
double jd1 = 2456122.0;
double jd2 = -0.374222409930591;
Using the NuGet package, SOFA C code (included in WWA source), liberfa I get these results:
pvh:
[0, 0]: 0.36358010848826561
[0, 1]: -0.87098205453928734
[0, 2]: -0.37758762761290249
[1, 0]: 0.015790881726547225
[1, 1]: 0.0055821572243759544
[1, 2]: 0.0024205553276501913
pvb
{double[2, 3]}
[0, 0]: 0.36128697138855309
[0, 1]: -0.87287395759745723
[0, 2]: -0.37843009179223269
[1, 0]: 0.01579627642463895
[1, 1]: 0.0055793863254509539
[1, 2]: 0.0024192303211176313
However if I run the same sample against the latest version of the WWA.Core source code I get different values:
pvh
{double[2, 3]}
[0, 0]: -1.4380401993025114
[0, 1]: 48.13081001851485
[0, 2]: 50.496624675136189
[1, 0]: -27.461656603117383
[1, 1]: -6.0043648152940641
[1, 2]: -3.2004034785635462
pvb
{double[2, 3]}
[0, 0]: -126.01563483201413
[0, 1]: -483.45362327412374
[0, 2]: -192.50804596930107
[1, 0]: -23.1220935093395
[1, 1]: 7.7476382322272448
[1, 2]: 2.7227051476989335
I see there were changes made to epv00 in Feb 2022, just not sure if it's expected that the result values have changed?
I noticed this because I was originally looking at wwaApco which seems to have a similar problem.
Given this input:
double jd1_tt = 2456122.0;
double jd2_tt = -0.3742224074074074;
double[,] ebpv = new double[2, 3] {
{ 0.36128697, -0.87287396, -0.37843009 },
{ 0.01579628, 0.00557939, 0.00241923 }
};
double[] ehp = new double[3] { 0.36358011, -0.87098205, -0.37758763 };
double x = 0.0012483996718683275;
double y = -2.4191277780194476e-05;
double s = 2.8198440882641448e-08;
double theta = 5.868498244632704;
double elong = -1.2915436464758039;
double phi = 0.7208209810736581;
double hm = 390.0000000015527;
double xp = 5.663587362550585e-07;
double yp = 1.973470449982449e-06;
double sp = -2.8551432482925797e-11;
double refa = 0.0;
double refb = -0.0;
When I invoke wwaApco using the NuGet package I get these results:
along: -1.2915436465043553
bm1: 0.99999999512048543
bpn: {double[3, 3]}
cphi: 0.75126413350351118
diurab: 0
eb: {double[3]}
eh: {double[3]}
em: 1.0165646807820918
eral: 4.5769545981283493
phi: 0
pmt: 12.530118487590943
refa: 0
refb: 0
sphi: 0.66000166796093673
v: {double[3]}
xpl: 2.0531311761394749E-06
ypl: -4.567827 644945285E-10
If I use the latest version of the source (as well as SOFA C code & liberfa) I get this:
along: -1.2915436465049144 // Last 4 digits different when compared to NuGet package
bm1: 0.99999999512048543
bpn: {double[3, 3]}
cphi: 0.75126413350351118
diurab: 0
eb: {double[3]}
eh: {double[3]}
em: 1.0165646807820918
eral: -1.706230709051797 // Different 4.5769545981283493 compared to -1.706230709051797
phi: 0 // -9.2559631349317831e+61 for SOFA, 2.999580946071453e-67 for liberfa
pmt: 12.530118487590943
refa: 0
refb: 0
sphi: 0.66000166796093673
v: {double[3]}
xpl: 2.0531311761393859E-06 // // Last 4 digits different when compared to NuGet package
ypl: -4.567827 0628706951E-10 // Different after the 6th digit when compared to NuGet package
So wwaApco seems closer to what I expect in the lastest source, but wwaEv00 seems worse.
Not sure if this is expected or if I'm doing something wrong?
Thanks
Greg
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: