From 1300379806f9d8fa933c21372cb4ba334ce74931 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Matteo Bongiovanni <40599507+MatBon01@users.noreply.github.com> Date: Tue, 24 Jan 2023 17:53:26 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] Finish ethics checklist (#14) * Update ethics checklist * Use the checklist change to add detail --- report/ethics/ethicalissues.tex | 2 +- report/ethics/ethics-checklist-ug.xlsx | Bin 13432 -> 13437 bytes 2 files changed, 1 insertion(+), 1 deletion(-) diff --git a/report/ethics/ethicalissues.tex b/report/ethics/ethicalissues.tex index c609ed6..fdb83c0 100644 --- a/report/ethics/ethicalissues.tex +++ b/report/ethics/ethicalissues.tex @@ -11,7 +11,7 @@ \chapter{Ethical issues} % 1-2 pages It is worth noting that the early stages of the project involves implementing the ideas created in \cite{RelationalAlgebraByWayOfAdjunctions}. This causes no legal issues as there is no protection on an idea, lacking the tangibility (and ability to be patented) \todo{See exact laws}. On an ethical level, despite implementations, improvements and building on work is commonplace, encouraged and vital to the academic community, one of the main contributors of the paper is my supervisor and I interpret this as implicit consent. With good referencing practice, plagiarism would also be completely avoided. There is an interesting discussion to be had on the ethical impact of the benchmarking dataset to be used in the early stages of the project. In order to evaluate the suggestions in \cite{RelationalAlgebraByWayOfAdjunctions} a database system will need to be implemented, but more consequentially one or more data sources will need to be used to evaluate the queries. I do not think that creating a novel data source will be very useful or worthwhile so I will need to acquire at least one somehow, raising at least two issues. -\subparagraph*{Data protection} The immediate issue that springs to mind would be whether the data source contains personal data and if so the subsequent data protection methods required to fulfil my legal and ethical obligation. To avoid this issue for primary data sources, I will not collect data when creating a benchmarking database, instead opting to randomly generate records. For data sources I acquire, they will all be in public domain already, and avoid sensitive personal data. This should minimise the risk to individuals affected. \todo{See if this is enough} \todo{Cite data protection laws} +\subparagraph*{Data protection} The immediate issue that springs to mind would be whether the data source contains personal data and if so the subsequent data protection methods required to fulfil my legal and ethical obligation. To avoid this issue for primary data sources, I will not collect data when creating a benchmarking database, instead opting to randomly generate records. For data sources I acquire, they will all be in public domain already, and avoid sensitive personal data. This should minimise the risk to individuals affected. The data protection laws consider "organisation" and "structuring" as processing personal data, hence why this is relevant. The databases acquired might need to be reorganised into the data structured explained in this report \todo{cite}. \todo{See if this is enough} \todo{Cite data protection laws} \subparagraph*{Database rights} Another consideration when outsourcing database collections, is the extent to which those who have created the database are protected. The creation of a database, although not creative, has been recognised as taking significant work and so those that create the database have a form of copyright protection on their work. \todo{Make sure that this is accurate, cite if so} This risk will be mitigated by ensuring that all databases used are in the public domain and the correct licenses are acquired. \todo{Potentially comment on the distribution of my implementation} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/report/ethics/ethics-checklist-ug.xlsx b/report/ethics/ethics-checklist-ug.xlsx index 21d5c130ce3487ba53ea91c1ea755e106b69aec4..d8060129bb393f6a699f65221591f5e956083568 100644 GIT binary patch delta 3985 zcmY+HWmFUj)5mwIMPdm-Qo6fSSV~|Cg{9$ABHby7xa86yORg*pB8`O964EFv-5t`U z5=y=IKIc8>KF@rZGw00z%%?g3`OTHntyAq00e+sQ@|ryI2LT_PN4dlRMOHN-WpuRA z!J-S6=`OF!c1Iab-(6Q16zkSUd#J`jgrj|Huo%VLhKiP-O6d-;mxRf0w)FG|Q)6`z z9v#BVc(M!R`jkTWBV+8-yOZ++WFIU(9-F{c9|ywNg5o53JyCNu+q&^Qcx*hiC~>|H6CjbSU?d?M(_;B0{^tWNMst@-%#+9 z)W3A!eDui!@S;yfJozz?&psPwj_~7PT*RV0qpUoBC+*!_G#70Lo`ptUxmiJRhO0P^ zQw?{>7UV)9flQ@VKB@aUMdkT8$N}qx)#|$+% zkInC)yk9SB&$8Xs(C^ zd10R>GU2_3&nf~DKi*XQj`p z!e_jDlm2GNyZR<76lzX+=1R=+O-GKL%pQW*$%mC*AV(5iEwOY;P=fd8kwSvhLmE->3TK+KZJ_R zT~SrdOX))!h`ZTumCYge+rJh&oe>!88C#2M54z=jnxnao^=)>AX^SK+GJp?EWFHni zekP@t4v)#is*3E*DjGC>4D}9eyCgBQoG;HP82lVtgrhB?3c}k_=;nM17{vis&`ukKAoLS{$jc= z5P-iuDWt@d6}AL&S@Eie5Sil;?Iba^;@|@S?o>z*Dmr942_ZabL4+J}!himlZ57!Y z<`qL&(d0CpUS7U`;pLw5pe|-}O6o)PpX0~!Kw}jZCyKy?&EI!)*VvnNmIE8m0^#&l zBtrB-{(3q2h#WTr{sdggA(A19UtxqRD;v&A7Jqs2J-9@=6sHzQNsmMhFG$6+_3)>B zi!6^K$V=1Gc7UJNSZS0_cM;`r9Pq?$dUIquX=)7qQXnzP2=9TNRYmp(kdsQ*n|6Lw zbA2W;bkYqim0k?!N_V5Eqin3zAma?%nxAadM^(8TUMp!NfIx|>c<>%%f^{b>HQd$S z&{>s3!*XQy2wP~@dzJ0Cd~ZoB7bkHT+15qO7i0mIfGgCe61!cg&s~xD4wTea@%a3p zyvzft?<20na&m9k_`P_m;9&y5@VBeT8FLn1vFB7EZ;2 zu-?LRz1ge;p}UH-H{UA}HKVD`nsyRx^=Dci6E_uX9TJB7eRIS%jSutf-V`@4-<KLuY|0yClSbvU>drv~Alvj74nb~@@=qLB_hJ{`F&GJ!!!biI``_}~hxuW1bo{LZh z=RkKw(oLvb&RC#SPX1|PyMA7D9k!^b-pX18p5YS_dQ-hOcRr_Dy3PaTHrUUo_GO2A z+yeoC`+LAYDJOH;G?q$apBez5H+-*t*m-{fl(R2)@W@ zb`3VV4P4S^yj>i(zMQc&SY0etoJgKf^flZDw{D|E5FWN&O#G zK#0Z;LeP;jLm(q6p}|q8K6j6LdFl@yBL{KZ2_q5P(;G2%d_mX&UEl5fxvZu+)=(H~ zYc8z)dgz6-tVu?(h@gpcBXRvWBb=j(W*9|Pdj2O}-8ZGdiq93Mb}&a-cO9xFFt<>d z@ijoQoi3k*t}>&q(nvIC%#DMpySKt#QY8E#&qk~Xf4);;ZGW|fD5vM8YN&RnE%_eh z1;n*5WU0`{yB&{Na}SpuQdw7F0uW0=E9Jhmu&oq|%KX+;ngb-IA7mvZf#>%-v?jyi zwR#Ye0T$FA2~7l}F-_`YgUI$6PFhnoW9LYyX-TE%K{wk}V53Ws1F5T>3$Fj@AxfnQlIUm3WkZp&FTb#f1vR1yGzNS9j-JZ~bzSN= zd<;%h)#aJVa`%tZ%f7JXp}asD=FB$X-PSqUVV2W4y1ZKYmk*reoI9t5i1 z;?|Q>98-V=Sl6Mdci~yXwabe;=0l3aa9ao*7@qLXM)zAFMX6=Oc62IpCLaB@<0g zvn$-6IANAu_1({BQOWN?o)_lP*UHSt13jXS6hq?`LLtp^C!_<{=)mUHcbOw$4+p|B zsxJ(KExBX{Z0tcWi}8A&Rc8tyb?^wP`Yop!b1dw4}~{S~Ry`&z$Du zi;yeDm%mb|^ZktJhK&q)u<$ISKcTgousFJCK%g`X>c6{qXx9yC4_!*YSbK0EJO-xJ3^^Vc*ao;dCwV}*(FVE>FrCVv!vS3-}!m48%D{!IxQBp!O zH{6b5jx=%FP~oJtNdY0^U)IG;0cHe`U0lr8GZ zG}i}Sr2jkLxTv_R0^B`vm;UELKyod#l{`_Sb*+^8d;({JBIyA7HTIiWj?HesrzKm2`xl?r(@7LY5sV!M7%i%Y9PN4yN8w zqTo|29>PNYWL60M3vz)~r-@h(mSeIc<<5+_6UW(Vw_#sEO9yNKZ`B*R50&EyS#D9r znAqgQS6b+uF5Mn{ZD%Fgw52(&Z948uy{zr*B>4h8tMGF86gZ5JaLA{FfJ#J7)bsV(^FCp`8!>2C#@vYDsR*FKL}8txCfA(%W$!mH0(7+M7ncG9CpsBJQ?0 z0J}hMcavSX_y$)62%0}KC5GuB#nq{qcjGq<)?1|}Z>7Iv9w^ciF^86i_so^8N1uxE zNirI?3b&|b(5@J+Ib`q2H9uHo*G)>5gKMewxoa*7d8?!ALg#wL|1% zcD*F%_k*b*7E2OEjB2!|Y?h#xPqs%3I6HcK(K7@FPa1875fr>Kh~DE2LoOC`Y5Lgxs!S2aRkKyAGFawoS#9-Gq`epJ=IxpD0ysDt zg@DRw zj8q72blh1fiIUfXM-=O1`J1wOOLvwg5{YKnoXVcxvb$!O=q67wg*22U+IMCI#fZS6 zwyYM<>guY4dNx2Ewbl~xze*!buFu+p(C4c?QlQPV>F#_*Q8TcOgoQfJxOT)>({*H$W2#0kiEwYefO!gtBOOF$fM-GC~ z=@Wbyi3zQdawAVFE-P~ea-GzXRpI_vWLbq4V^)wSlelLYvvr%)Vg%U&3f~qP{?ew{ zXhDMbN4wd!Zz?{Odh86nX$m{uk3q=WvXYA8^V6*=++=!{N9j6c#TF?vY9{*hTf}~B zI&3{^a4**oZV^OB!Lz~6LZJDhKJEn|5vSgmmB_0iHd!d2tX3=96B(LHWxm^GlkfIr zH!6Ou?bJhAr8*1UUlcEnUck&4`v5d9T*uhYykvC1lT+%4dEt(_Ne6(2#dF7vNB#VC~W4ZyCyY!rV|7`v^D0&paW=g*Ge%t|FltTefqut4iM5vE|ME3_ zd8hK5S)J`G>h~t~(bl(k(&rdv)k68k-`0ITC>jA_M}`3Fk&SFi-dz0DzABLsp|>1l zV6OXCo&Lm+65~hA+n#{>TK*IK|Nm@@MPWb<& o*$w31;CG4x08spQ8*qliiYo%!kYEV~U@B5af{TD&^dG_h0a;6jYXATM delta 3963 zcmV->4}|djX!vNb?FI$e5)Vi{lkx^Ce`r9ZQ%8bUX`8Bc>t2v12b^Nn*vvLfs%igy z*HF@?*+aLX#2@%_eD3wR*Qf7xEqCsz(oBjB;hB#dDk@nsahsv9UkZ1D9BqiG373Lq z=z(hV?(FTG)2&o@Yboy>01!GujWJ#7dAe$7OY}^3RKUtcs+Jg-s#{NYijrD4f0UY* zdx7uAUQ3ujBSNZPgCRE?R?(%b`j!eaf+)&~0s6XOou1Iz>NRjJQFndkRyWPd zOj>(V966k5v#Ob)b%su0D!26Dh3dQaJ>#$%L`kqf-q~Kxm&&Q>hV3w(u^R4G~Oe@kK-r&l~f zWx3US#$`o#Bef~Nu6tp6H}GeEST?eyC8XY3iqbSxGhHg$No7iE8dmA@nS9A{uKb07 zNoAwrL0CrW8@d4vXJdZJG?t7jXzC zt+s(4G0H&CrAV8AReF4&rq6A)oc#RpIGB*Y zI#w4<>Kbx#1WO(k@88Y$+H7nE-~uGnHYb&H%`A#6uRt*y>IQ0@DYa3|;eW4LN47D* ziq=WVD2d}yq?o8lN0^y=7`iM4ho$CQ1-0uS1|)MBzpX@LPc+5v!6{}o+h)MEY7ns! zQn+IaC4u6zr**9jTS?6OKvTwpgTXh!Z+Mbv$FG!>;6__rx)8}x7xQ)c(`XtoekNV# ze;0SrxUnYFoL$&x(O+V~Eeox~xjF;P?TE4-m>VMjSwC}2_ACE_j!+$6I z>)vT->wDMM1O71WGdJeT&rRY(rDtiE@vJDx&q`ub4Z+ zC{+1+*vQ-9CW_fRfY>cg8fWizp+{f!5?@Rdv*&~% zja)rrjBv78xXjzCQgtzcWVSU#iQ+6#IWSQXn#kBTQGcwhoF}A_+scR{wAG@-Yioif zP{b0WX7xCj*i}jzu^uQwjZrgO&KlClwv08jh~yIx?2s}y0LPq1)u@r}8Ij0-BObsI zPBXyCL>k$?XrO_}M3b8MUSbYTnEU_%&K%Onb-gs#KseX{pKM4Y+egSG4;m1X2{@TZ zBil#FlvA;$!$Ai)nIMNuP(&u9W@B=KOhniDl#>U16NQ_4);QpVB8}Kq%?OogZ-*k! zo|B3)%l1W6kq)m>I(3hVFi1YgbjTnbT&X+;xwUM^liFQE|C6p0yR**`G!X>FGn5#U z2O~2Fj-%pIDiB7KK_e_Q9p03N7VLv|cE9y%_hpONW-ixuzTdiGbNnHyrPE;=x`=UN#4g9S2&v+EeA-A2?0gE}U5~6?LgBRmw-5=}Orc z4)1??ef#S!U0jYP{iDfXG^Ei9UGy)8-mSDT!sOx8utDHbZ?hYqAes2M-y1wbfu zdhICGe!fZv1*tsuV6{!> zy(9e0ockiDIcB?0m(HyAp!}{x1U7WeLZ~pywHQ#_J+cFXmR$KIf7O9s9MTDj;Tu&} zhG~0ulBALwXw zHJn@y`p*cE^MZ|Nciz~E2lN}!2D1k(B7pR3TJj{Ep!^tX<1jJ%6n=6wNo4gTjo? zFiPNAkebRef9Lb$iq|?8WO%NFSvfDvPiBb(gO8R^sT26iRL*Mef!b=F@JJ4^zF~)n zq_aT({Pj1<>}u28xG4fnfd;1kHLJ>5)H5UO7=dz3GGC|81LtJ{37p&}H9?Xa zqi2PD86XNHYMts<$^F))^TGIk2~HWth66A=tKv*2viAmw?j6P62Sq zs^Jt7f3*j;2Jigx8OckkcPJ5kM9vDEvKCD=)nwQ|*PFveKfr}y(5V{(*hN!Vp5r(g zQkNC%9oN{^GU@fa!0*jUEE;Y$t;*|#%Ahw)(m85gZ4vkN_X3K6fOTm0iOpHD#UwU8 z=az0%xE4V}ed-@sv%G40r1t2eMQtqmwai0=e@O}p*>Z}Fb}L{L@n*Kcc!Hb9taSBn8tVo&hK3sO-}ol)SsLVj>cOs>Y>tA&Dbei3bOLR zFqNI91@?BU#Xi6mv|`9&+Y34eo08-PNuN1%th+zWhMP}1>i!{o_4ZK*f8rhd3zI<# z6a?fD-O{rIDJB7blEH4NY3Bnv35maVg}AO{HK zPJI4UtDY<8;mNxmJQ@gDB-y}KzaX!OJ*PCNSLkGzMTL!j#f|fw#2EU9_EP